- Oct 14, 2020
- 2,020
- 3,301
Never before for Sage, she's always been on the DIK path.There has always been different dialogue depending on CHICK/DIK. That's nothing new.
Never before for Sage, she's always been on the DIK path.There has always been different dialogue depending on CHICK/DIK. That's nothing new.
I think the thought process here is that Sage is tied to the DIK route so it's odd that there are scenes with her that only happen if you do something CHIK.There has always been different dialogue depending on CHICK/DIK. That's nothing new.
This is very similar to the discussion that's going on about the Jill/Sage choice, where when you do something thoughtful by helping Sage you loose with Jill who's always been on the CHIK path. It's just kinda game-y for a visual novel.I think the thought process here is that Sage is tied to the DIK route so it's odd that there are scenes with her that only happen if you do something CHIK.
Add this to your reasoning and I do not think that a girl who likes you is very happy that you reject her romantic date for going to help another girl, no matter how much friend she is, because she may think that the friend is more important than herself ... I at least think for myself. If I'm dating a girl and I go to her house with a surprise date for her birthday and she dumps me because she tells me she has to take care of a friend, I would take it a little badly.Not also Jill's characterization, but MC's too. He's been a kind, supportive guy, and that's why Jill likes him so much. He has promised a friend in need to be there for her and then Jill come out of the blue and invites him to a surprise date. All while being in a emotional conflict thanks to Tybalt, so I can even understand she takes this date like a turning point ("does MC really worth it...?") Problem is the in-game MC is not aware of this crucial detail. We as players know what's happening and that kind of info asymmetry is something I never liked in games, because it's forcing me to make a decision in the name of a character that doesn't have the same inputs than me, so immersion is broken. I'm choosing like "me, the external player", not like "me, my in-game MC". And I hate that.
Well, what I say is that the man Jill has started to love would probably go to confort a friend who he knows that needs him (and who he has promised to help) instead of having a selfish, nice date with a girl that, in that moment, he can't possibly know that also needs him to step forward for her (of course, she never tell him that, and he never comes up with a rain check). And by making that most logical choice according to his previous behaviour he's closing the door to the girl that, till this point, was more aligned with his character. Emotional manipulation and lack of a proper communication, that's the only way DPC knows to do things, time after time.
Nobody dumps anybody. MC made a prior commitment and 'punishing' him for it by subtracting Jill points if he decides to honor it seems counterintuitive when Jill is all about dropping everything to support friends in need and going out of her way to 'help' people (like when she reported Chad). That's what this boils down to.Add this to your reasoning and I do not think that a girl who likes you is very happy that you reject her romantic date for going to help another girl, no matter how much friend she is, because she may think that the friend is more important than herself ... I at least think for myself. If I'm dating a girl and I go to her house with a surprise date for her birthday and she dumps me because she tells me she has to take care of a friend, I would take it a little badly.
Which is absolutely hilarious because women hate it when you try to make a date without giving them a 2-3 days notice.Not also Jill's characterization, but MC's too. He's been a kind, supportive guy, and that's why Jill likes him so much. He has promised a friend in need to be there for her and then Jill come out of the blue and invites him to a surprise date.
That I can understand, but note that for a Neutral/Chick MC is not that the friend is more important than her, is that MC's word to a friend is more important than anything else, especially when he doesn't have enough inputs to properly weight the situation (had MC now beforehand what Tybalt is doing, that this might be his last chance to be with Jill, well, maybe priorities can change). Until this point, Jill has been a nice, sensible and understanding woman who likes to do good things to her friends. How can MC imagine she, from all the people, is the one who's going to cut ties with him for not being "free" to accept a surprise date?Add this to your reasoning and I do not think that a girl who likes you is very happy that you reject her romantic date for going to help another girl, no matter how much friend she is, because she may think that the friend is more important than herself ... I at least think for myself. If I'm dating a girl and I go to her house with a surprise date for her birthday and she dumps me because she tells me she has to take care of a friend, I would take it a little badly.
I know but that's why you have to choose, if Sage is just a friend or fuck buddy and Jill is your love interest you know who to choose and vice versa. Sage has the flu, is something normal , nothing serious and you can go with her at any other time or day, the birthday date could only be there.Nobody dumps anybody. MC made a prior commitment and 'punishing' him for it by subtracting Jill points if he decides to honor it seems counterintuitive when Jill is all about dropping everything to support friends in need and going out of her way to 'help' people (like when she reported Chad). That's what this boils down to.
Sage path does not requires any affinity status. You simply agree to teach her how to play guitar and you agree to fuck with her when she offer it, and you to became fuck-buddies .Well considering everything else on the Sage's path either rewards you with DIK status points, or requires you to follow a Neutral/DIK affinity it's a bit unusual that you now have to go CHICK for the same character. Or are you one of those fan's of games where you have to play with a guide open so you can follow all of the un-intuitive twistings and turnings just to navigate the game?
That could also work exactly the opposite way, don't you think? The birthday date (MC's birthday was the day before, btw) could be easily postponed to the next day. Tomorrow Sage could be OK, is today when she needs helpI know but that's why you have to choose, if Sage is just a friend or fuck buddy and Jill is your love interest you know who to choose and vice versa. Sage has the flu is not normal and you can go with her at any other time or day, the birthday date could only be there.
But be serious and speak for yourself, think for a moment what you would do, I repeat myself a lot but here you must choose the one you consider that you want to have something serious with her. If it's Sage, go to her and what Jill thinks, well is her problem, since you don't see her as something serious, because I don't think she stops talking to you (regardless of blackmail), she'll still be your friend but nothing more. I dont see the problem, if you date multiple girls at time you can be hurted xD and I know it from my own experience hahaThat could also work exactly the opposite way, don't you think? The birthday date (MC's birthday was the day before, btw) could be easily postponed to the next day. Tomorrow Sage could be OK, is today when she needs help
If I had 19 years old and were torned between Sage and Jill, I'd go to Sage every day. Most people interested in Jill would go with her, but that would mean breaking with all what your character is. The point is that this exact situation (going to a surprise date vs staying true to your word given to a friend) being the turning point for Jill is non-sensical (considering how the affinity/RP system has been built so far) and highly unfair for a Chick MC who's unaware of Tybalt's machinationBut be serious and speak for yourself, think for a moment what you would do, I repeat myself a lot but here you must choose the one you consider that you want to have something serious with her. If it's Sage, go to her and what Jill thinks, well is her problem, since you don't see her as something serious, because I don't think she stops talking to you (regardless of blackmail), she'll still be your friend but nothing more. I dont see the problem, if you date multiple girls at time you can be hurted xD and I know it from my own experience haha
I don't mind DPC including a fork in the road choice between Sage and Jill. I just wish he wouldn't have made the choice so counterintuitive. No matter how you slice it, helping a severely ill friend (male or female, fuck buddy or not) is a Chick choice and Chick choices are Jill's bread and butter.But be serious and speak for yourself, think for a moment what you would do, I repeat myself a lot but here you must choose the one you consider that you want to have something serious with her. If it's Sage, go to her and what Jill thinks, well is her problem, since you don't see her as something serious, because I don't think she stops talking to you (regardless of blackmail), she'll still be your friend but nothing more. I dont see the problem, if you date multiple girls at time you can be hurted xD and I know it from my own experience haha
Well... in my case it's not a question of pursuing someone or not. In real life I am the kind of person that when says he is doing something, then he is... that's it... If I say yes to a certain plan, I am not changing my answer almost no matter what. Of course there could be extenuating circunstances, but I dont think that's ever happened to me. More like the other party cancels the get toghether or whatever it was. So even though I am pursuing Jill, I feel I have to go to Sage on that moment and in real life you probably would not loose points truth be told. It's a "friend" (at least as far as Jill knows) and is sick.But be serious and speak for yourself, think for a moment what you would do, I repeat myself a lot but here you must choose the one you consider that you want to have something serious with her. If it's Sage, go to her and what Jill thinks, well is her problem, since you don't see her as something serious, because I don't think she stops talking to you (regardless of blackmail), she'll still be your friend but nothing more. I dont see the problem, if you date multiple girls at time you can be hurted xD and I know it from my own experience haha
But MC being seen as making a 'relationship' decision if he goes to take care of a sick and depressed Sage when she's essentially friend-zoned him makes absolutely no sense... Beyond that, the right thing to do would be to go to the friend you know needs you rather than pursuing getting your dick wet by going on a date with Jill, and I could've sworn Jill was into people doing the right thing...But be serious and speak for yourself, think for a moment what you would do, I repeat myself a lot but here you must choose the one you consider that you want to have something serious with her. If it's Sage, go to her and what Jill thinks, well is her problem, since you don't see her as something serious, because I don't think she stops talking to you (regardless of blackmail), she'll still be your friend but nothing more. I dont see the problem, if you date multiple girls at time you can be hurted xD and I know it from my own experience haha
This is where, again, I feel the affinity system of this game proves its flaws. DPC is trying to put certain characters on certain paths that align with this largely undefined system that seems like it's intended to be a metric of the MC's personality, but his actions should speak far louder than a character's pre-designated alignment, and not just those of the Major Choices.That I can understand, but note that for a Neutral/Chick MC is not that the friend is more important than her, is that MC's word to a friend is more important than anything else, especially when he doesn't have enough inputs to properly weight the situation (had MC now beforehand what Tybalt is doing, that this might be his last chance to be with Jill, well, maybe priorities can change). Until this point, Jill has been a nice, sensible and understanding woman who likes to do good things to her friends. How can MC imagine she, from all the people, is the one who's going to cut ties with him for not being "free" to accept a surprise date?
What I'm trying to show is the inconsistence with the way the game has being handling relationships and characters so far, and also how almost every big choice is presented in an unfair way just because in the last moment DPC decides that characters can't speak as loud and clear as they usually express themselves. We are playing a game and the dev is playing us, that I don't like.