3.50 star(s) 129 Votes

Zed | Love-Joint

Love-Joint Team
Game Developer
Dec 18, 2018
242
727
If another family member tells you something like that about your Mum, it can be very easy to be shocked and not think straight + worry about 'evidence'. Its a game that builds with story each month, we still have chapters to go so maybe not assume and wait to see what happens before making assumptions?
 

TheKryptonian

Truth, Justice, and TheKryptonian way...
Donor
Nov 22, 2018
1,201
2,089
If another family member tells you something like that about your Mum, it can be very easy to be shocked and not think straight + worry about 'evidence'. Its a game that builds with story each month, we still have chapters to go so maybe not assume and wait to see what happens before making assumptions?
I really hope your right mate because before the aunt showed up Amanda was one of my favorite characters in all these games. But then chapter 13 happened...
 
  • Like
Reactions: McWoodz

Zed | Love-Joint

Love-Joint Team
Game Developer
Dec 18, 2018
242
727
I really hope your right mate because before the aunt showed up Amanda was one of my favorite characters in all these games. But then chapter 13 happened...
Have faith! insert red dead joke. But things have to happen to build a story, otherwise it will be the same repetitive stuff.
 

JoeSte91

Member
Apr 12, 2018
237
460
But. Chapter 14? I seriously don't see the issue. There is a clear romantic and passionate relationship there. But the "issues" needs to be resolved.
You can't just use sex to indicate a 'romantic and passionate relationship'. She's cold and distant, or as you seem to suggest, thinking things through and trying to decide who to trust, in every other scene, then bam, she's up and willing. It feels fake and manipulative rather than the romantic and passionate that you were trying to convey. Regardless of the issues involved, it's a terrible way for the daughter to handle it, especially considering that the choice is between an unknown entity and her only parental figure, one that she's in sexual relationship no less. There should be some benefit of the doubt there.
 

Palmer

Member
Game Developer
Sep 26, 2017
285
840
I don't understand when you say "uncertain" when its obvious she has already decided who she "trusts" and its not the MC.
I think you are misinterpreting the game. Maybe we didn't make that point clear enough. Hope it becomes it more clear for you when you play the later chapters, if you do :) Have a good evening bud!
 

Josh M Spicer

Well-Known Member
Sep 19, 2018
1,292
1,770
We'll get it a few months and if it turns out that playing the later chapters changes nothing about how we feel, than hey, I guess you can do you being passive-aggressive.
 

bllahbllub

Active Member
May 5, 2017
840
2,429
The Diner is the problem how could Amanda be so invested into the Diner??? The Diner was there her whole life or not?
Since when does she work at the diner she should know that "her diner" isn't made out of gold.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
She made a plan to turn the table and make the diner to a profitable diner or not?
How could she believe a woman that was never there for her and her Mother.
Why does Amanda not thing for a sec and ask a question why the Billion Dollar Aunt shows up now???
Amanda is my daughter or not why is she ignoring her life? She has a father that owns a diner he raise her her whole life or not?? She works with him and loves him more than a daughter should.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Sex is Sex without Trust how can i think that she loves/trust me?
Because we had Sex come on my incest daughter wants just the D!!!
Tell me whats on your mind daughter nope Father i just want the D!
 

recatcher

Newbie
Feb 16, 2018
66
48
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

I honestly appreciate the "this was executed badly" complaints more than a "man I used to like her but then she had to go and have her own opinions about shit" complaints.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

As for choosing "better girls"... We haven't really seen any of them tested, per se. Throw uncertainty and conflict the other characters' way and who knows how they'll do. Heidi might be the most balanced one, honestly. Kathy and Lily would both flake out, with references to bongs or pop culture or somesuch. Kathy's been known to just run off, and Lily was introduced as someone whose tendency was also to deal with things rather randomly.

Y'know, maybe if we'd skipped chapter 13 things wouldn't be feeling so dire. It has a few sex teases but just doubles down on the mean uncertainty in the main plot rather than inspire SOME hope.
 
  • Like
Reactions: IAmTheGrim

recatcher

Newbie
Feb 16, 2018
66
48
She certainly does, if one that's formed by a biased influence. It's clearly a flawed one (separate issue) but the point is she's doing something other than playing that part she's expected to play. Her own ideas, i.e. not just going with the player's preference.

And she's always had her own opinions. She believed the diner was worth saving. She wanted to get the jukebox fixed so much it became a plot arc of its own. She wanted the MC. She has opinions about Lily, Heidi, and Moe.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Alfius

bllahbllub

Active Member
May 5, 2017
840
2,429
She certainly does, if one that's formed by a biased influence. It's clearly a flawed one (separate issue) but the point is she's doing something other than playing that part she's expected to play. Her own ideas, i.e. not just going with the player's preference.

And she's always had her own opinions. She believed the diner was worth saving. She wanted to get the jukebox fixed so much it became a plot arc of its own. She wanted the MC. She has opinions about Lily, Heidi, and Moe.
But why does she ignore her life with her father he never betrayed her during the 18 years or did he?
There shouldn't even be a opinion that involved in believing her aunt.
Amanda wants only the D of her Father..... that's how i see it know.
 

recatcher

Newbie
Feb 16, 2018
66
48
See, that's another opinion of her own. we're free to agree or disagree with it but it exists.

But why does she ignore her life with her father he never betrayed her during the 18 years or did he?
There shouldn't even be a opinion that involved in believing her aunt.
Well, that just provs my point then.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

As for wanting the d... I guarantee you, if a woman is in such an emotional mess as she seems to be in (and the consensus seems to be she's pretty deep in that), the last thing they're going to do is put up with your shit to get your d. Plenty of d out there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Breestis and Alfius

bllahbllub

Active Member
May 5, 2017
840
2,429
See, that's another opinion of her own. we're free to agree or disagree with it but it exists.



You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
No it isn't an opinion She wanted to fuck her father because she is a horny ass bitch.
She doesn't care about her Father only the Diner counts???
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 

recatcher

Newbie
Feb 16, 2018
66
48
...that's an opinion. I think the character model for Kathy is hot, and if I were a reasonably attractive datastring of 1010100001100010101010 and not a person (or better yet, if she were a person) I'd love to get with her. Opinion.

The rest:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PPE2RedDucks

bllahbllub

Active Member
May 5, 2017
840
2,429
...that's an opinion. I think the character model for Kathy is hot, and if I were a reasonably attractive datastring of 1010100001100010101010 and not a person (or better yet, if she were a person) I'd love to get with her. Opinion.

The rest:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
I said pissed yes but whats she does is throw everything her Father gave or did for her her whole life out of the windows that is not being pissed but being an ignorant little bitch that should know better that her father would never do something like that.
For me that just shows how much she doesn't care about anything (Diner Friends Love Father). There is no Room for something like that if you care about the person that raised you alone!!
Maybe if she was a teen that could explains things but as an grown ass woman who runs and works in a diner with her father!
A big fat Nope for Amanda and her actions!!!
 

Avaron1974

Resident Lesbian
Aug 22, 2018
26,409
91,050
See, that's another opinion of her own. we're free to agree or disagree with it but it exists.



Well, that just provs my point then.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

As for wanting the d... I guarantee you, if a woman is in such an emotional mess as she seems to be in (and the consensus seems to be she's pretty deep in that), the last thing they're going to do is put up with your shit to get your d. Plenty of d out there.
None of that is her opinion, that's her aunts opinion pushed onto her.

She's backed off because she has no opinion of her own and doesn't know what to think.

The problem with your last statement is she's still getting that D. So this money stealing, mother killing arsehole is still railing her pussy.

Not only does she carry on with the kids tantrum she still wants her lolly pop at the end of the day.
 

recatcher

Newbie
Feb 16, 2018
66
48
That's how opinions work. I like the band Queen. That's an opinion I came up with, but not without influence from my dad who got me to listen to the band. Opinions are formed with bases.

"Backing off because she doesn't know what to think" is normal in a case like this, but that's because it's a huge decision that needs weighing, and not because she has no opinion of her own. Hell, the choice to back off is also her opinion -- she doesn't outright stay (what the MC would want) or leave (which the aunt would want). Her choosing to figure things out in some way is her own idea. I've already conceded that her staying at the aunt's place is a bad look for the story being told.

It's hilarious that you demand more sophisticated thinking from her but are completely fine with "yup she's only sticking round for dick" to explain her actions, completely dismissing any possibility for complexity there.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 
3.50 star(s) 129 Votes