I haven’t seen them all yet. But
in my opinion, based on what I have seen and read, it’s the Villain harem endings, as far as overall satisfaction. The monogamous endings just seem sad to me in this game, and all of the Hero ones are monogamous-only, as far as I know. Which, for this game, with its particular characters and events that potentially unfold, feels like a disservice to not even have the option.
Breaking Katherine’s heart is something I don’t think I could do (though, luckily, if you go Villain and decide to go full Sarah, Katherine doesn’t even care enough to comment on it apparently! Which I’m guessing was an oversight?
). And as I’ve mentioned in other posts, I personally hate that there isn’t a Katherine & Sarah ending, as I was all about her character too. With all of the setup, buildup, and foreshadowing I felt there was for the option for those three to become a throuple, it currently feels like there’s a cut or missing 9th ending.
That’s just my take though.
But the silver lining (for me anyway) is that I think using many of the assets from the existing endings, one could throw together a modded ending that works and fits the bill. Maybe even one with Andrea and co. too, with some creative writing. But for me, as great as the rest of this game is, Katherine+Sarah was the #1 thing that I personally wanted. Everything else was a distant 2nd. So it may not have been as much of a disappointing blow to a lot of other people as it was to me lol.