I just binged through the whole thing and I absolutely must hand in something like a review and/or constructive criticism. So this goes to you, Ptolemy:
First of all, I loved this. The writing - It's funny, it's hilarious, I love every single character in the game. The Lex Luthor scene had me in stiches. You are a brilliant writer - Of something that isn't porn. Because my dick twitched about twice during the whole game. I enjoyed myself a great deal playing through it, but I couldn't not nut to any of it.
Now the question is, why is that. I think the first part was that within 5 minutes of playing the game, you're boning the secretary. Pacing, brother! Don't do that. I couldn't even NOT bone her and at the beginning of the scene I was still convinced this was some kind of Trap (as in: Tranny) because of the manface on Andrea.
Which brings me to my next point: The renders - There's so many bad ones, I was laughing almost as much at them as I was at the writing. The renders are terrible, but please, do not change a thing! Fuck the renders. Phone them in, crank them out, if you spend 5 minutes on renders that you could spend on your writing, you've just wasted 5 minutes. This isn't really criticism or anything, I just want to touch that subject.
But where I believe I can help you most is by telling you this: Your life sim is terrible. Nothing is more of a turn off than having to bang a girl 50 times to get her sex points high enough so you can see the next scene WITH A DIFFERENT GIRL. This life sim code? KILL IT WITH FIRE! Rewrite the whole thing to be just a classic, straight forward VN where all you do is choose what girl you have your next encounter with. It'll be much more pleasant for you to write new scenes, and much more pleasant for the player. The storylines are too intertwined and ultimately linear to make any sense as a life sim. You already got so many great scenes. Scenes is where you ROCK. Life sim is where you SUCK. Maybe add a gallery mode so players can review their favorite scenes. It'll instantly make pretty much everything about the game much better.
And finally, the characters. They're all so adorable and alive with their funny dialogues, even when they are in desperate need of a professional spell checker. I'm 'dyeing' to see you get enough Patreonbucks to hire a copy editor.
Dana is pretty much perfect if bland, but the story around her is paced badly, mostly because it's shoehorned into an inept life sim. If anything to improve her: She needs to be more horny and less in control of herself, and as a consequence more ashamed of herself, to make her a central figure in a game where you're supposed to nut. An appealing female character must always balance shame and shamelessness, which Dana never does - She is never ashamed, and thus she is never shameless. But essentially she serves only as a vehicle to explore the more colorful character cast.
The supporting characters all have, in my opinion, a grave flaw that makes them unappealing to me as a choice for "Beard" or otherwise friends of the incestuous couple, if still great to read.
Andrea - Oh I know girls like that in real life, the sort that literally regress to being 10 years old, so emotionally needy, can't stand them crazy bitches. You know the sort where you have a friendly romp through the bedroom, and afterwards she curls up in a ball in the sheets and starts crying. And asked why, "Oh it's nothing, I always cry after sex because it's so nice". JESUS I DONT MIND MAKING A GIRL CRY DURING, BUT NOT AFTER SEX. But apart from my personal dislike of IRL girls like that, Andrea comes off as alive and compelling, just begging for someone to fix her incredibly annoying emotional neediness and make her regress to at most 15 years where girls can at least be naughty and somewhat independent, but still insecure enough to be cute.
As for the pacing issue at the beginning with Andrea, I guess what's happened is that you started writing her character interactions at the very beginning and basically didn't know what you were doing yet so you'll probably change things around when you go back to writing the beginning of the game. Just don't force me to fuck her in the first 5 minutes of the game. And how retarded is Dana if she thinks Andrea might be CEO material?
Jessica - So when this character finally showed up for me (after hours of grinding up useless stats without hitting the right triggers) I immediately pegged her character. So here we have a lesbian, a gold star lesbian even, who - in the heat of the moment - decides to give up her gold star by banging the Brother of the girl she's been lusting after for years. And to do that, she puts on the airs of a dominatrix. GEE I WONDER WHAT PSYCHOLOGY COULD BE AT WORK HERE!
Obviously as a gold star lesbian she would be extremely insecure engaging in sexual relations with a dude, especially one she barely knows (or only knows of him that he's a big womanizer and yet still wants to plow her bald ass) and overcompensate this insecurity with her habitual dominatrix act, which indubitably would have helped her a great deal securing bangable, masochist-tending, bi-curious girls. What the Jessica Plotline needs more than anything is a way to tame her. She calls you "kitten" - that is obvious projection. She is the one who wants to be the kitten, she is the one who finally wants to feel like a girl after she spent so many years building up her tough guy / dominatrix façade. Also, I kinda dig bald chicks. Just saying. Just don't dig the eternal dominatrix act. Thankfully you can tell her to tone the act down (or at least not crank it up) at some point. I can get behind worshipping a girl like that for a bit, for the reason that she's otherwise too insecure - but that shit has to stop eventually and she'll have to learn to give herself into my capable hands.
Maria & John Finally we have the swinger couple. I guess some would say that to fix them, all you need to do is shoot John, but me personally, I greatly enjoy the dynamics of John & Maria, especially as the MC can tell John that he'll tear his dick off and feed it back to him if he so much as touches the Sister. Beautiful. Bravo, my man. I feel understood.
tl:dr:
- Keep up writing funny scenes, you're great and that's what you're great at!
- Screw the renders, the eyes are on the text box anyways.
- Rework the whole thing into a linear, branching VN and remove the "life sim" stuff that doesn't work
- I'm fucking serious about that - "remove the life sim part" - which is why I'm writing it twice
- Let me tame Jessica!