In a lot of games, we see a girl giving blowjobs and the MC telling how skills she is, but she's either a virgin and never sucked a dick before, or she was with 1 or 2 partners. So, it's not uncommon.
Also, the fact she says MC is so good at this can be a lot of things, doesn't imply she was with a lot of people too.
I don't say I'm 100% right and you are 100% wrong, maybe I'm wrong or not, but with what we know dans with what we can interpret, nothing makes me believe that Melanie was with a lot of people.
Lot of possibilites here, maybe she had a boyfriend with whom she did some things but her betrayed her really bad? Maybe not? We don't know exactly but it's look like she doesn't have a ton of sexual experience like you said. We didn't see dialog about MC knowing Melanie has some boyfriends, her mom also never said something about her daughter's dating live, so we don't know for sure. At most, she probably has little to some experience, if my understanding is correct.
For the MC, you see him differently when he moved, but it's still very plausible that subconsciously he was afraid and/or didn't want to let people in his life. The fact that he was in love with his sisters can also play in that mindset, again like I said, subconsciously.
I didn't claim that Melanie was not a virgin anymore. I only said that her behavior doesn't match the fact that she is very guarded against people, and was since they were kids. and that behavior would suggest that she COULD have lost her virginity before, but it would be very surprising for the same reason.You are making some pretty strong assumptions based on pure speculation that is unsupported in the game so far.
Knowing Prom, it is very highly likely that Melanie IS a virgin. His comments about her in Discord confirm it, too: in response to someone asking for her to have a genital piercing, he specifically said she wouldn't have let anyone outside the family near her pussy. Also, even in the highly unlikely event that she is not, dialogue will not bring it up, because it's not going to be relevant to the story if she isn't.
Age doesn't give you an answer about virginity... We have confirmed virgins significantly older than Melanie. There is even a character literally multiple thousands of years old who has retained her virginity specifically to give to the MC.
Apparent experience also doesn't give you an answer about virginity, because porn exists. I have personally been with two definitively-confirmed virgins who were quite good at BJs/HJs due to having watched porn, and one of them was significantly more experienced at cunnilingus than I am, but was still a virgin.
What can give you some hints here about what is likely:
Fundamentally, Prom is a harem fan, and was one before starting this game. He is not likely to make very many of those fuckups devs commonly make when they're trying to cater to harem fans without understanding harem games, so there's no reason to start in with unfounded speculation. For that matter, you could always... ask him. He's generally pretty forthcoming with things that aren't vitally important plot spoilers. That's how we know what Dawnchaser is, what it's like, and who is in it, and why we know that that one weird cuck-obsessed dude who's been ranting about the Dawnchaser MC inevitably cucking the Evermore MC is so full of shit... Prom is open and honest about his games.You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
even if she is naturally gifted and very open, and especially eager with MC, there should be signs of shyness or hesitation if she did all that for the first time. she could have practiced all that by herself, or with porn, sure. but still, when it actually happens for the first time, there are signs. you could dismiss it all by saying "hey, porn/AVN logic" but i instead link it to a promiscuous lifestyle that contrasts far too much with her main personality trait. maybe the dev wanted to give her too much of the big sister trope. it would be better, for me, if she was very eager because of her feelings for MC, very motivated but still a bit clumsy/sloppy. it wouldn't change the character. and MC having no one to compare it to could just like it and appreciate it a lot.
it doesn't break the game anyway. it's just a detail that i found surprising.
Reyna being a virgin is also surprising to me. maybe the dev officially said it, i don't know. but from what i understood in the game, she already had some experience from the first god of creation.
Titania has children, so she probably isn't a virgin. maybe she is in regards to human dicks though.
Marianne, nothing in the game confirms her virginity. did the dev say anything official ? when MC has sex with her, it doesn't seem like it's her first time.
I think it is implied that Aria gave her virginity to MC in later interactions, even though she seemed experienced in the first scene. and she spent all her time with her brother, and pretty much has a brother complex. at least, that's how i understood it.
Chloe, given the kind of life she had up until MC, it's pretty much guaranteed that she is a virgin. Bella has more chances of not being a virgin than Chloe, honestly
I think there could be a scene with Melanie and Layla. or a threesome with MC.