3.80 star(s) 64 Votes

Le_Eng1403

New Member
Jan 13, 2022
12
14
I know this is unrelated but here is an example of dev try to take advantage of their customer and got completely overwhelmed by those fan recently.

>Make a good hentai games
>Make a sequence so that you can make more money from "milking" fan
>Sequence has no sex scene in early access
>People complain, dev stay silence
>Fan thought sex scene is hidden somewhere, required specific way to unlock
>Play even harder
>After 1 year of release, dev announce out of nowhere that game won't have any sex because "we were not clear enough about the "16+"content rating when we released it in early access"
>Instead of adding sex, they told people can refund
>Somehow in order to refun, you'll have to provide personal information, steam account into a third party website and receive your money from Alipay app lmao wtf just for 2 fucking dollars)
>Everyone's mad
>Go bankrupt recently

PH must be treated even worst than this since at least these guys know how to make a game. 1678511633484.png
 
Aug 13, 2020
311
662
I know this is unrelated but here is an example of dev try to take advantage of their customer and got completely overwhelmed by those fan recently.
-
That's pretty brutal, I got those 2 games... even the minigame one, for the lulz. I did notice the lack of sex in the sequel, but it just hit me as a totally different game, besides being 3D it was more of a softcore dating/VN thing. However I never minded it that much since all the MirrOr games are dirt cheap, and the original one was pretty much a generic match 3 H game, so my expectations were fairly low.

On the other hand we have Fallen doll, operation lovecraft, paralogue or w/e it's the actual name is, with funny pricing, high expectations, lies lies and promises, promises. It's a wonder it's not gone down already.
 

Nihil5320

Member
Jul 2, 2022
365
925
That's pretty brutal, I got those 2 games... even the minigame one, for the lulz. I did notice the lack of sex in the sequel, but it just hit me as a totally different game, besides being 3D it was more of a softcore dating/VN thing. However I never minded it that much since all the MirrOr games are dirt cheap, and the original one was pretty much a generic match 3 H game, so my expectations were fairly low.

On the other hand we have Fallen doll, operation lovecraft, paralogue or w/e it's the actual name is, with funny pricing, high expectations, lies lies and promises, promises. It's a wonder it's not gone down already.
I think the difference is in the lying, there were some parallels in the communities response to that game and FD up until they explicitly confirmed it wouldn't contain any adult content. Users were still on the forums saying it would add adult content after EA, there was adult content buried in the game files etc. right up until they confirmed otherwise in much the same way FD superfans always see a working product as being 6 months or so out.

Still a different situation though. They seemed like competent devs and they produced a game in a fraction of FD's development time, they just unwisely chose to let users believe the game was something it was not.
 

SweetCupcake

Newbie
Mar 2, 2020
33
32
I know this is unrelated but here is an example of dev try to take advantage of their customer and got completely overwhelmed by those fan recently.

>Make a good hentai games
>Make a sequence so that you can make more money from "milking" fan
>Sequence has no sex scene in early access
>People complain, dev stay silence
>Fan thought sex scene is hidden somewhere, required specific way to unlock
>Play even harder
>After 1 year of release, dev announce out of nowhere that game won't have any sex because "we were not clear enough about the "16+"content rating when we released it in early access"
>Instead of adding sex, they told people can refund
>Somehow in order to refun, you'll have to provide personal information, steam account into a third party website and receive your money from Alipay app lmao wtf just for 2 fucking dollars)
>Everyone's mad
>Go bankrupt recently

PH must be treated even worst than this since at least these guys know how to make a game. View attachment 2457735
Ive watched this unfold since the start, was satisfying to read their last post.
 
Mar 5, 2023
29
85
I know this is unrelated but here is an example of dev try to take advantage of their customer and got completely overwhelmed by those fan recently.

>Make a good hentai games
>Make a sequence so that you can make more money from "milking" fan
>Sequence has no sex scene in early access
>People complain, dev stay silence
>Fan thought sex scene is hidden somewhere, required specific way to unlock
>Play even harder
>After 1 year of release, dev announce out of nowhere that game won't have any sex because "we were not clear enough about the "16+"content rating when we released it in early access"
>Instead of adding sex, they told people can refund
>Somehow in order to refun, you'll have to provide personal information, steam account into a third party website and receive your money from Alipay app lmao wtf just for 2 fucking dollars)
>Everyone's mad
>Go bankrupt recently

PH must be treated even worst than this since at least these guys know how to make a game. View attachment 2457735
In fact they still have some differences,。
the development of Mirror is a game company for more than ten years , although they only do some web games and steal other games resources for their mobile games.

they took all the money which earned in Mirror into a new project Novastella Island
they wanted to make a new genshin impact ,but no one have experience in AAA game projects.
in this time ,other companies report them for making pornographic games, which is illegal in China
So the boss disbanded the team

but Project Helius, they are hobbyist of porn games who know each other on the internet
no project manager, not full-time developers , the whole project is a mess
 

Terix3

Well-Known Member
Aug 2, 2017
1,099
1,619
You know you fucked up when even patreon whales stop supporting you lol
Did they tho ? If you inspect the recent days he gained 1k patrons compared to last month and the beta is not even playable. Like literally it been up for 2 days i think absolutely broken and down for maintenance since then which is close to week now.
 

taboge9459

Member
Nov 16, 2021
238
643
Did they tho ? If you inspect the recent days he gained 1k patrons compared to last month and the beta is not even playable. Like literally it been up for 2 days i think and down for maintenance since then which is close to week now.
That's because graphtreon doesn't work on a day by day basis. Within the sub style Helius is using the only useful datapoint is the last day of any given month as that corresponds to his income, someone canceling mid month has still paid and so is still counted for that month. If you only look within any given month Helius has never lost subscribers, even though looking at the trend over time is he's down 10k. We'll need to wait 2-3 months to see how the number pan out to account for the spike of newcomers coming in before the update in anticipation, and then for people to remember to cancel.

Just take a look at the numbers around the November release if you want an idea of how the numbers will behave going forward.
 

Terix3

Well-Known Member
Aug 2, 2017
1,099
1,619
That's because graphtreon doesn't work on a day by day basis. Within the sub style Helius is using the only useful datapoint is the last day of any given month as that corresponds to his income, someone canceling mid month has still paid and so is still counted for that month. If you only look within any given month Helius has never lost subscribers, even though looking at the trend over time is he's down 10k. We'll need to wait 2-3 months to see how the number pan out to account for the spike of newcomers coming in before the update in anticipation, and then for people to remember to cancel.

Just take a look at the numbers around the November release if you want an idea of how the numbers will behave going forward.
You compare given day of month to same day of last month it doesn't need to be end of month. If someone cancels the sub they paid for that month but they are not factored in total current patron count and that is the graph we are seeing. Obviously to gain better picture you should compare full month to another full month and compensate to whatever events could have impacted it.
 

taboge9459

Member
Nov 16, 2021
238
643
You compare given day of month to same day of last month it doesn't need to be end of month. If someone cancels the sub they paid for that month but they are not factored in total current patron count and that is the graph we are seeing.
Nope, that is not the graph we are seeing. Graphtreon is meant to estimate earnings, so it counts subs paid in a month to get that estimated earnings per month figure you see, not active subs. If you sub on a new account and cancel right after, that number will increase by 1 for the sub, but then not decrease for the unsub since you've still paid in for that month and it contributes to earnings. It will only decrease in extreme circumstances like refunds given afaik (or anything that may affect the earnings).

If it helps you think of it, you have an accurate snap shot of current subs at the start of any given month, then newly gained subs are appended on top of that to give a rough estimate of earnings (not active subs mind you) for any given period within the month. That puts it slightly different to a live sub count. Set the scope to a year to see what I'm talking about, it's way to get the discontinuous leap frogging on the first of every month as opposed to a continuous trend like a live sub count would provide. See the live twitter subs for this, that one is continuous since it is a live sub count.
 

Terix3

Well-Known Member
Aug 2, 2017
1,099
1,619
Nope, that is not the graph we are seeing. Graphtreon is meant to estimate earnings, so it counts subs paid in a month to get that estimated earnings per month figure you see, not active subs. If you sub on a new account and cancel right after, that number will increase by 1 for the sub, but then not decrease for the unsub since you've still paid in for that month and it contributes to earnings. It will only decrease in extreme circumstances like refunds given afaik (or anything that may affect the earnings).

If it helps you think of it, you have an accurate snap shot of current subs at the start of any given month, then newly gained subs are appended on top of that to give a rough estimate of earnings (not active subs mind you) for any given period within the month. That puts it slightly different to a live sub count. Set the scope to a year to see what I'm talking about, it's way to get the discontinuous leap frogging on the first of every month as opposed to a continuous trend like a live sub count would provide. See the live twitter subs for this, that one is continuous since it is a live sub count.
How sure are you about this?
I believe that the numbers on grapheon are snapshot of supporter count on patreon site. Doing sub outs I have observed that the number of patrons does actually drop.
I went hunting and found this :




On those graphs i found drops mid month. Do note that detailed day to day graph is only available for last month and after that grapheon does some averaging.
 
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: taboge9459

taboge9459

Member
Nov 16, 2021
238
643
I only do buy ins - i sub in and sub out. I've observed that that that the number on patreon goes up when i sub in and then drops down when I sub out. The number on grapheon is simply once a day snapshot of numbers shown on patreon.
Here you can see grapheon that has curve drop mid month.
If what you say is true mid month drop would not be possible .
I pointed out refunds and other earnings affecting things can factor into it. If you wanna see the behavior difference I am talking about:

1678542588218.png
Notice it's discontinuous and leap frogs, since subs renew on the first of the month. Compare that to live subscriber data, it's continuous since that stuff updates throughout the month.

1678542801487.png

Aaand looking into it some more it seems like my assumptions might be slightly off, since Patreon now seems to go by sub date as opposed to first of the month like last time I used it. Not 100% sure how that would affect graphtreon.

1678542987597.png

You're still better off comparing peak to peak or trough to trough so that whatever causes that leap frogging isn't affecting your in month data.
 

taboge9459

Member
Nov 16, 2021
238
643
How sure are you about this?
I believe that the numbers on grapheon are snapshot of supporter count on patreon site. Doing sub outs I have observed that the number of patrons does actually drop.
I went hunting and found this :




On those graphs i found drops mid month. Do note that detailed day to day graph is only available for last month and after that grapheon does some averaging.
Not too sure anymore, looks like Patreons renewal policy changed since the last time I used it :(, which makes this much harder to gauge lol. There is still something causing that first of the month behavior though, so maybe subs from before that update? Looking at those it's only recent that the mid month decrease is happening.

Oh, found the new behavior.
 

Terix3

Well-Known Member
Aug 2, 2017
1,099
1,619
Not too sure anymore, looks like Patreons renewal policy changed since the last time I used it :(, which makes this much harder to gauge lol. There is still something causing that first of the month behavior though, so maybe subs from before that update? Looking at those it's only recent that the mid month decrease is happening.
I think that the end of month drop is caused by renewals not being processed, lack of founds, the bank requiring confirmation from user or maybe simply users waiting for end of month to unsub. Maybe some payments simply take few days to get counted.
 

taboge9459

Member
Nov 16, 2021
238
643
I think that the end of month drop is caused by renewals not being processed, lack of founds, the bank requiring confirmation from user or maybe simply users waiting for end of month to unsub. Maybe some payments simply take few days to get counted.
Yeah it's going to be hard to read graphtreon going forward with this new update style. The patron count should be more accurate, but now the earnings will be off since you don't know how many leavers canceled before paying for that month.
 

Nihil5320

Member
Jul 2, 2022
365
925
Yeah it's going to be hard to read graphtreon going forward with this new update style. The patron count should be more accurate, but now the earnings will be off since you don't know how many leavers canceled before paying for that month.
If you're looking for the impact of a single event it will just be a continuous decline over the next month instead of a sudden drop at the end.

Or at least it will be once the grouping of subs around the 1st lessens. I doubt it will disappear entirely due to common paydates being 31st/1st of each month.

Where sudden subscriber drops are significant we should be able to infer the impact a lot sooner though.
 
3.80 star(s) 64 Votes