Great game, the writing in the sex scenes is S+ tier and it's a lot of fun in general, even though most of the kinks I've seen so far have not been my taste, but I'm far from having seen everything.
That said, is there a way to avoid Penelope while getting to Lily? I love Lily, but being made a girl by Penny is a HUGE turnoff for me, so having very sexy Lily scenes in tandem with Penelope scenes that are kinda disgusting to me is grating.
And, just meant as feedback: I've started the game with Butters after Moxy told me about all the girls and said Butters was shy. "If I'm into shy girls, I should visit the alchemist." Well yes, I am! I expected a shy innocent girl, maybe something like Lily turned out to be, although she wasn't shy with MC either. Instead I got an experienced dominant lady and am forced to watch her getting it on with the surrounding plant life. If I hadn't been able to tell from the writing and art style that I would love most of the rest of this game, I would have stopped playing at that point, it was very frustrating. I guess what I'm trying to say is, introductions of girls should be clear and not misleading in my opinion, also any scenes involving LIs being penetrated by anything other than MC should be optional or at least skippable.
Still, great game, with outstanding writing and great art! It's unfortunately in the nature of things that criticism takes more space than praise, so I hope I don't come off as too negative. This game is a gem and I would not have thought I would enjoy it as much, as I have had no past exposure to the pony thing and don't know the characters.