- Nov 24, 2019
- 1,985
- 4,607
- May 28, 2017
- 4,371
- 13,335
Then don't. It's not the intent of the game to play it dozens of time. Play your character and make your meaningful choices. You are not forced to replay. If you find you want more, choose another character and play it differently. And so on.
I never understood "too many variations" complaint. How can there be too many? The more variations there are, the more you can play your character the way you want. The more of an impact you can have on your character's story. An ideal game would have thousands of variations where pretty much the player's imagination is the limit...
- Jul 1, 2020
- 67
- 129
- Apr 25, 2020
- 5,081
- 14,093
I mean it's not so much the fact that there is too many variations but rather how you get them : talking to certain characters at certain times and/or ignoring some content like missions. But like I said I'm not a fan of sandbox games, so there is that
- May 28, 2017
- 4,371
- 13,335
OK, the point of Sarah's games is to play with her. You are effectively winning by just playing (unless you do some things she doesn't like in CoC). You don't need to actually win those games. So if luck is not favouring you, no problem. There's no need to get frustrated. If you lose the VR game twice, you still get to progress to the next one. So no grind. If your character dies in CoC, no problem, you can just roll a new one in the next session. Point is she'll be happy you played with her. So again - no grind.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
- Sep 20, 2018
- 3,419
- 14,166
I'm not sure I can agree with this. Yes, you can just sit down and play through the game once, but the result will be, in my experience, extremely unsatisfying if you're looking for a structured story. The game does a very poor job of connecting our actions to the variations we get. As a result, a lot of what happens feels extremely random. Yes, some of the biggest choices have some clear consequences: deciding to blackmail Sarah, or fraternizing with Annie after being told repeatedly that you'd better not be caught doing that. But the vast majority of the choices are smaller, and they have a very circuitous route to their consequences.
To really get a sense of how our actions are directing events, we need to either play the game through multiple times or look "behind the scenes" at the underlying code. Likewise, trying to advance a particular task (repairing the station, for example) often boils down to a depth-first search of every available option. That's what can lead to the sense of grind, since a player winds up doing a whole bunch of things they didn't enjoy in the hopes of finding the one that they do.
That at least was my impression back in Chapter 3, and it does not sound like it has changed since then. The game seems to be embracing and expanding on the sandbox elements - which is fine for those that enjoy them, but tough on those who were hoping for the intriguing story elements to take center stage.
IMHO, obviously.
Last edited:
- May 28, 2017
- 4,371
- 13,335
Well, ironically, as much as I enjoy freedom of choice, it wouldn't do it for me if I didn't like how well the story elements connect. I don't think any of the scene ever felt random to me. The story is always evolving, regardless of the direction you take. There is always a cause and an effect. You don't get stuck in a loop of - here's a part of the game you don't enjoy that you need to complete to progress to the next one - that many "sandbox" games tend to have. I don't like the term sandbox here, because open world elements don't constitute a sandbox. What you choose to do, where you choose to go, who you interact with... those are all choices that move the story and substories forward.
Now with great choice, comes a great responsibility, so to speak. So, yes, the player, in theory can make a series decisions that can be against his best interest storywise. This game heavily relies on the player paying close attention. It has its difficulty in that sense.
The story, as a whole is, I'd argue, is very well structured. Chapter One is more focused storywise. You get introductions to the main characters and to the setting before it moves to a dramatic event with a cascading series of malfunctions and becomes very story-driven at that point. Chapter Two, goes back to the introductory phase. To set the stage that is centerpoint of the game. Chapters Two, Three and Four are what I would call quiet before the storm. These are chapters of exploration, investigation and getting to know the characters. Chapters that build up the mystery. The center story goes into background. I don't know what will happen next, but I'll bet that with stage set, the story will rapidly gain momentum.
I think a mistake a lot of players make is they don't try to see a big picture. They want payoff now, and when they don't get it they're unhappy. I bet that if you played the complete game, you would speak differently. At the current stage of the game there are far more questions than answers. And rightly so. I think those who don't have the patience for the journey should wait until until the game reaches its destination. Then I believe, a single playthrough tailored to player's choices will truly shine.
This game is a one of a kind in what it is attempting to accomplish.
Last edited:
- Apr 28, 2017
- 433
- 809
- Feb 23, 2018
- 849
- 1,598
This is only in a spoiler because it's another one of my characteristically long wordy posts.
Seriously, this may be one of the longest posts I've ever written. Sorry not sorry.
The TL;DR is: the game's design is very intentional and won't appeal equally to everyone, it is what it is.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
Last edited:
Boy, this game is a whole lot of nothing! Or maybe I am just spoiled by better games like Summertime Saga, Being a DIK, Mifly City, Holiday Island, Where The Heart Is, and Treasure of Nadia.
Whether you think it should be that way or not, for me, and maybe some others, these purely random defeats were frustrating. I also don't see the point of including this path if it is not linked to a corresponding complexity in the player's decision.
Imagine a story in which the MC was offered a training session before this fight, which he could have refused and thus he would not have been prepared. Ideally, the MC would have learned in the training how to read his opponent, so that the player could select the correct responce and win the fight by "skill". That is gameplay. Simply selecting a path at random is pointless and simply frustrating.
dunno if already reported, in one of my playthroughs at the start of the free roam section i first went and modified the shower then watched the scene with Markus and went for the fridge, at that point it was impossible to access the toolbox cause the image of the hole in the shower was instead showed. after that i guess the save was completely corrupted cause i kept on getting weird renders being showed randomly of previous scenes and finally even being brought back to ch 2 content.
apart from those strange bugs, this is the first chapter of this game where i really didn't enjoy the gameplay, i usually like RPG-ish games where you're supposed to roam around and solve puzzles or find stuff, those games that i like tho (EON for example) have a pretty good built-in guide to help you if you're getting stuck unable to guess what to do to catch all the scenes that you missed.
my first playthrough of ch4 lasted less than 15 mins, couldn't get any of the content, then i had to go back and figure out from the script which variables i was missing in each of the paths of my saves. i also agree with some of the other comments in this thread, both the pool and the VR games become way too grindy if you want to win.
i'm sorry to drop this game cause i was really enjoying the story, just like it happened with Deluca family, there too i couldn't stand the new gameplay, in that case though the developer has already let know that a VN version of the game will be be made available in the future, i hope this game too will have eventually one.
apart from those strange bugs, this is the first chapter of this game where i really didn't enjoy the gameplay, i usually like RPG-ish games where you're supposed to roam around and solve puzzles or find stuff, those games that i like tho (EON for example) have a pretty good built-in guide to help you if you're getting stuck unable to guess what to do to catch all the scenes that you missed.
my first playthrough of ch4 lasted less than 15 mins, couldn't get any of the content, then i had to go back and figure out from the script which variables i was missing in each of the paths of my saves. i also agree with some of the other comments in this thread, both the pool and the VR games become way too grindy if you want to win.
i'm sorry to drop this game cause i was really enjoying the story, just like it happened with Deluca family, there too i couldn't stand the new gameplay, in that case though the developer has already let know that a VN version of the game will be be made available in the future, i hope this game too will have eventually one.
- May 28, 2017
- 4,371
- 13,335
Not think, I know that for a fact. You don't need to win these. If I didn't like games of chance, which I do, I wouldn't bother trying to win. You're making it frustrating for yourself when it doesn't need to be. It's your own fault.
You can sort of learn to read the opponent in the VR, if you notice that the animated combat stance of the orc is not always the same. So "skill" can play a factor, albeit small. There is of course still luck involved. And as the player progresses throughout the VR campaign he will unlock new skills, so... do you see where I'm going with this? Do you play roleplaying games? Because when you play a roleplaying game with dice rolls, your character doesn't have the "skills" at Level 1.
If there was a "I win" button it'd be dreadfully boring. That's not gameplay.
I find it curious that so many people who play adult games have aversion to all kinds of gameplay. Desired difficulty: none. They should
- May 28, 2017
- 4,371
- 13,335
I'll have a look later and pass it on. Thanks.
- Aug 25, 2016
- 797
- 1,892
Thing is, that's down to the series having the best ecosystem design in gaming, with many different behavioral routines interacting to form unpredictable and entertaining outcomes to player decisions. That way, the emergent design of the game becomes a much more personal experience - the stories it generates are your own. In comparison, the plot is a predetermined linear route from start to finish, with a handful of choices along the way.
But even though the story has to almost 'get out of the way' for the player to really have fun, there's still plenty of discussion about the plot from Vice City onwards. A lot of it has even been enshrined in meme culture - "Ah shit, here we go again..." "Hey cousin! Let's go bowling." "All we had to do was follow the damn train, CJ!" San Andreas in particular has standout performances from Sam Jackson and James Woods, they sold the hell out of their characters. Plus, the radio shows alone from the earlier titles have more great writing than you'll find in most full games.
---
As for H5 itself, it's hugely impressive what Notty is doing. More power to her, and I hope she's able to finish the game the way she's visualised it. I've also discovered that it's probably not a game for me, and that's perfectly fine. Time-gating and FOMO aren't things I typically enjoy in my games. I don't mind being locked out of paths based on decisions in games like Dark Souls, where the intrinsic gameplay loop of improving myself as a player and character is rewarding on its own. But in more pure exploratory games like this one, I can feel it pinch a little sharper.
I think that's probably aggravated by the episodic nature as well. Even in games where I've done multiple playthroughs, it's almost always start-to-finish as one playthrough, then do another run with different choices and paths. Can't do that with episodic releases, you'd have to mentally separate one run as your 'canon playthrough' and the others as experimental variations, and that's just not how I like to play.
Hopefully, the workload stays manageable. Like someone had mentioned, the problem with having so many divergent paths is that the work required increases all the time if new choices continue to be added. I'm guessing at some point the game would have to soft-lock you into a path and give you only minor choices from then on (or find a way to mix-and-match aspects of different playthroughs), otherwise each subsequent update would either be even more time-consuming to produce, or spend less time with each path.
Anyway, whenever the game's done, will definitely be interested in giving it a shot from scratch. I know that's probably years from now, but I should have that long. I hope.
- May 28, 2017
- 4,371
- 13,335
Theoretically, yes. But, I think the best approach is not to try to get this one and let it appear naturally in future chapters. More sessions played, the more likely it is to have its prerequisites met.
Yeah fair enough I was just curious because i've finished my main playthrough and just wanted to see some of the other scenes, still a brilliant chapter release either way
- May 28, 2017
- 4,371
- 13,335
I agree that the game would best be played when finished. It does have drawbacks to play it chapter by chapter and it's not for the impatient. I'd recommend you to try it after Chapter Six. That will be a conclusion of Part I (as the game will now be split in two halfs) and it should bring some story resolutions and endings. Part II (Chapters 7-12) will then have its own releases importing saves from Chapter Six.