quinfax

Active Member
Jun 4, 2018
511
1,559
Crowdsource time!

So ....just rendered my first naughty stuff ( which is an aces scene if I say so myself) but how big a dick is too big?

I must have given the chap a decent eight inches. Too much?
6" to 8" are reasonable sizes to me before it becomes a little crazy.

You know what they say though "It's not the size, it's the motion of the ocean."

Excelsior

P.S. Did someone say naughty?

hqdefault.jpg
 

Frosty2000

Active Member
Nov 16, 2017
593
1,604
Yeah, he is the hero(or anti), he should not be below average, even if it is not massive, it should be 'healthy' to large. I mean, if you are going the fem-dom route, you might be into the micro thing, but I assume most of us want to play a guy who is at least as big as we are... So I would say 7-8 would be minimal for what is effectively a porn star. :LOL:
Well I am into the femdom route, and I don't need a micro penis for that. Just like to have it realistic. So 6-7 inches (15-18cm) would be my max, and is in my experience also more attractive to the majority of women. Besides I hope the femdom route would be a lot about tease and denial. Nothing breaks the control of a Domme over a sexually submissive faster than having him orgasm.^^
 

TheDevian

Svengali Productions
Game Developer
Mar 8, 2018
13,696
32,050
Well I am into the femdom route, and I don't need a micro penis for that. Just like to have it realistic. So 6-7 inches (15-18cm) would be my max, and is in my experience also more attractive to the majority of women. Besides I hope the femdom route would be a lot about tease and denial. Nothing breaks the control of a Domme over a sexually submissive faster than having him orgasm.^^
I didn't imply you needed it for that, just the only time I have seen it as desirable, some masochists get off on that sort of humiliation. Personally, I lost interest in that sort of play a long time ago, and just like flipping it. The best subs are also doms, and the best doms are also subs.

As I said before, I don't really want to play a guy in a porn game who is smaller than I am, it's ...distracting at least, so 7-8 is minimum. It's hardly unrealistic, I mean we are not talking about something like Summertime Saga's arm sized member. I once knew a guy who could almost reach his knee while still limp (he liked spandex). The hero is supposed to be the biggest, strongest, toughest, or whatever the key trait is in their role after all, and this is a sex game, so... :unsure:
 

SecretSal

Active Member
Aug 25, 2016
797
1,867
My thought for sex scenes was, with most camera angles from an elevated height, you have to deal with perspective issues like foreshortening. In those cases, a larger member helps the physical connection stand out a bit. This wouldn't be a major problem for animations, since you could still convey power/speed/technique in motion with an average-sized dick and have the scene work well. But if still images play an important part in sex scenes, then it could be a little underwhelming.

Again, not reflective of what size feels best for actual sex, but what might work for cinematic purposes. Like in porn, I'm pretty sure a lot of those positions aren't actually that comfortable for both parties, but they do it anyway for the viewers' pleasure.
 

Nottravis

Sci-fi Smutress
Donor
Game Developer
Jun 3, 2017
5,132
27,267
Thanks, guys. I've read and noted. I'll leave this conversation running without me jumping in for a little while longer yet though in case others have views we haven't heard from yet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheDevian

K18

Well-Known Member
Apr 19, 2018
1,008
6,998
Crowdsource time!

So ....just rendered my first naughty stuff ( which is an aces scene if I say so myself) but how big a dick is too big?

I must have given the chap a decent eight inches. Too much?
8 inches sounds decent and assuming the MC isn't short & scrawny-looking. Another thing to possibly consider is if the characters make a big deal out of the size or not in the dialog. Like, is the size is only mentioned rarely or is it always bought up by characters during naughty times. Maybe in the middle, maybe 1 character likes to talk dirty.
 

TheDevian

Svengali Productions
Game Developer
Mar 8, 2018
13,696
32,050
8 inches sounds decent and assuming the MC isn't short & scrawny-looking. Another thing to possibly consider is if the characters make a big deal out of the size or not in the dialog. Like, is the size is only mentioned rarely or is it always bought up by characters during naughty times. Maybe in the middle, maybe 1 character likes to talk dirty.
Yeah, with this crew, I can see them chatting it up about that kind of thing pretty often. :LOL:
 
  • Like
Reactions: K18 and Nottravis

Frosty2000

Active Member
Nov 16, 2017
593
1,604
I didn't imply you needed it for that, just the only time I have seen it as desirable, some masochists get off on that sort of humiliation. Personally, I lost interest in that sort of play a long time ago, and just like flipping it. The best subs are also doms, and the best doms are also subs.

As I said before, I don't really want to play a guy in a porn game who is smaller than I am, it's ...distracting at least, so 7-8 is minimum. It's hardly unrealistic, I mean we are not talking about something like Summertime Saga's arm sized member. I once knew a guy who could almost reach his knee while still limp (he liked spandex). The hero is supposed to be the biggest, strongest, toughest, or whatever the key trait is in their role after all, and this is a sex game, so... :unsure:
Well you could turn it around and say the opposite too, that having a way bigger penis than your own is distracting.;) It certainly is to me. Although I have to say, that in adult game terms, 8 inches is by far not the worst. Still given that it seems that roughly only 1 in 200 males has a penis of at least 8 inches, I am not sure your size (have you really measured it btw? ;) ) can be taken as a standard here.

Concerning being the toughest, biggest, bestest or whatever, I don't see the connection to penis size here. Maybe I hang out with the wrong people, but never did I experience penis size being a category for being seen as especially great. But yeah okay if we apply porn game logic, then... but so far NotTravis seems not to care so much about following the typical logic in those games.^^

Also again applying real life logic anything above 8 inches seems to be more of a handicap. The poor guy with a limp penis to his knee surely suffers a lot with this thing. Besides being fetishized by a small group of people, I really don't see much of an up side for this guy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nottravis

TheDevian

Svengali Productions
Game Developer
Mar 8, 2018
13,696
32,050
Well you could turn it around and say the opposite too, that having a way bigger penis than your own is distracting.;) It certainly is to me. Although I have to say, that in adult game terms, 8 inches is by far not the worst. Still given that it seems that roughly only 1 in 200 males has a penis of at least 8 inches, I am not sure your size (have you really measured it btw? ;) ) can be taken as a standard here.

Concerning being the toughest, biggest, bestest or whatever, I don't see the connection to penis size here. Maybe I hang out with the wrong people, but never did I experience penis size being a category for being seen as especially great. But yeah okay if we apply porn game logic, then... but so far NotTravis seems not to care so much about following the typical logic in those games.^^

Also again applying real life logic anything above 8 inches seems to be more of a handicap. The poor guy with a limp penis to his knee surely suffers a lot with this thing. Besides being fetishized by a small group of people, I really don't see much of an up side for this guy.
I didn't say I was 8, but that 7-8 would be good. I was just saying that it's not ridiculous, or unrealistic. Plenty of people are that size, especially in porn. Considering most of these games have a guy who is closer to 12-24 inches, I consider 8 pretty reasonable. :LOL:

As far as the connection to being the best, it's a sex game, so the hero should have the best dick, and be the best at sex (or learn to be by the end if it's that kind of game). I don't know about anyone else, but for me, I enjoy flipping the script on the femdom, and making her bow to you. Being one of the best is part of that, you can't be the hero of a sex game if you can't please all of the ladies all of the time. :sneaky:

Well, the guy I knew who was that hung was pretty proud of it, and there have been many who do porn with one like it.
 

Frosty2000

Active Member
Nov 16, 2017
593
1,604
Well, the guy I knew who was that hung was pretty proud of it, and there have been many who do porn with one like it.
I suppose owning such a "handicap" is a kind of coping mechanism. ;) But yeah it is a fetish for some, so at least in porn it has a market. Still being a porn star in reality is certainly not as "cool" as it sounds in most guys fantasy...

He can lower himself off tall buildings without a rope? ;)
Hmm you mean buildings the size of a doll house? ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheDevian

TheDevian

Svengali Productions
Game Developer
Mar 8, 2018
13,696
32,050
I suppose owning such a "handicap" is a kind of coping mechanism. ;) But yeah it is a fetish for some, so at least in porn it has a market. Still being a porn star in reality is certainly not as "cool" as it sounds in most guys fantasy...
Well, I used to only be an editor, but still, it's a living. ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nottravis

abgazil

Member
Jul 27, 2018
140
151
Long-time lurker that is using my first post to say:

1) This game is looking really good already - keep up the amazing work
2) I hope you won't shy away from exploring darker content. I find the promised option of being able to effectively be the 'villain' of the story most intruiging
 
4.10 star(s) 64 Votes