Akamari

Forum Fanatic
Donor
May 28, 2017
4,371
13,342
726
I think I might have identified what was throwing me off about the new Sarah render. What do you guys think?

New Sarah
429399_hi.png
My little crude edit of it
429399_hi_testedit.png
It's crazy, but this is all it takes for me to identify this young ensign as Sarah.:)
 
Last edited:

Akamari

Forum Fanatic
Donor
May 28, 2017
4,371
13,342
726
Allow me to illustrate my point further. This is my fav remastered render of classic Sarah.
412839_test8_2.png
Now, look closely at her lips. One thing they always did well was light reflection. If you zoom in to pixels, you'll see it's different shades of pink. Now, with the new Sarah there is a very bright white spot. Unappealing IMO. It throws me off, because that never happened with the OG Sarah.
 

Huitieme

Scholarrior
Donor
Game Developer
Oct 9, 2018
3,108
15,712
750
Allow me to illustrate my point further. This is my fav remastered render of classic Sarah.
View attachment 415937
Now, look closely at her lips. One thing they always did well was light reflection. If you zoom in to pixels, you'll see it's different shades of pink. Now, with the new Sarah there is very pure white spot. Unappealing IMO. It's totally off, because that never happened with the OG Sarah.
I would go as far as saying that if this is the only issue with the remaster, then it's a success. I, for one, don't mind the white spot on Sarah's lips (no sexy innuendo intended).
 

TomberryDude

Well-Known Member
May 22, 2017
1,459
5,787
729
Allow me to illustrate my point further. This is my fav remastered render of classic Sarah.
View attachment 415937
Now, look closely at her lips. One thing they always did well was light reflection. If you zoom in to pixels, you'll see it's different shades of pink. Now, with the new Sarah there is a very bright white spot. Unappealing IMO. It throws me off, because that never happened with the OG Sarah.
Oh ok now that you explain it I see it. It is distracting, for sure.
 

Akamari

Forum Fanatic
Donor
May 28, 2017
4,371
13,342
726
I would go as far as saying that if this is the only issue with the remaster, then it's a success. I, for one, don't mind the white spot on Sarah's lips (no sexy innuendo intended).
One clarification. I don't consider new Sarah to be a failure. It's great really. But this is the one misplaced piece of the puzzle that prevented me from going all excited like you guys. Literally one white spot which stopped me from congratulating Notty on achieving something I was very skeptical about. (Which she still did, just one little thing away from perfection).

I can understand it's insignificant to you, but for me it's a jarring difference because I had been used to something for 9 months and now it's completely different and she didn't click as Sarah because of that. I think this is something that should be tweaked to be faithful to the original. It's not an improvement. (Btw. the lips themselves do look better than the original, Notty really did phenomenal job remastering Sarah.)
 

Nottravis

Sci-fi Smutress
Donor
Game Developer
Jun 3, 2017
5,132
27,295
765
The new Sarah looks a little more mature and serious... Must be the new makeup and the change in hair colour.
She's absolutely yummy, to be honest.
And it's a very good thing you kept her eyes... They're mesmerizing.
I'm in love! :love:
Can't wait to see her in a dress... A white one, preferably.
Thanks :)

But it's the same hair. Just the lighting in the hanger has changed having switched from three point to all natural. Plus "old sarah" was an overlay. I didn't have the memory to have Sarah, Vanguard and the hanger. If memory serves it was three separate renders.
Allow me to illustrate my point further. This is my fav remastered render of classic Sarah.

Now, look closely at her lips. One thing they always did well was light reflection. If you zoom in to pixels, you'll see it's different shades of pink. Now, with the new Sarah there is a very bright white spot. Unappealing IMO. It throws me off, because that never happened with the OG Sarah.
The white spot is a reflection from the hanger lights.

Nope her lips never reflected light like that, no matter the light.
She had no natural lighting before.

I was under the impression that was just because of a reflection of the lighting applied in that picture, so i see no problem there.
Yep. Exactly that.
 

TomberryDude

Well-Known Member
May 22, 2017
1,459
5,787
729
Thanks :)

But it's the same hair. Just the lighting in the hanger has changed having switched from three point to all natural. Plus "old sarah" was an overlay. I didn't have the memory to have Sarah, Vanguard and the hanger. If memory serves it was three separate renders.

The white spot is a reflection from the hanger lights.


She had no natural lighting before.



Yep. Exactly that.
Welp, mystery solved I guess. I'll let the Scooby Gang know we don't need them anymore.
 
4.10 star(s) 68 Votes