- Jul 25, 2017
- 165
- 94
You used the mass effect example earlier did you know in the first game they had different voice lines for every character during the saving the council choice. each character had a internal renegade rating so the renegade would try to persuade you to abandon the council, the other would tell you to save them but the character who spoke wasn't fixed so depending on the pairing you could have the same squadmate in 1 playthrough tell you to save them where if you reloaded with a different 2nd squad mate would try to convince you for the complete opposite.A game with only 4 heroines isn't comparable to this one having like, 10. Sure, they could've not had as many heroines, and possibly done a branching story depending on how many of the magical girls you didn't let get captured forever.
But that's not the story they wanted to write. And honestly, I can't fault them. The amount of branching that could result with a playable cast this large is pretty massive - especially with how many chapters the game has.
If it was a like, 2 or 3 stage game, you could maybe pull it off. It'd still be a nightmare to write, I'd imagine, but in the realm of possibility.
Writing aside, it would also make game balance an absolute nightmare. The game is probably balanced around you having 5 active characters and up to 5 reserves later on. You'd have to create entirely new everything if someone decided to only keep like, Noble Rose (since she seems the closest to the main character overall).
Well its not so much the branching I don't think they need to go that far but they just wanted a linear story with equal spotlight on each character, they could've easily written it so if one character is absent another one takes up their role but it is what it is.
Abaddon is probably one of the best written ones, you should really check it out if you want to see how a game with party members who can die works out, it's possible for everyone except the MC to die and the story still plays out, and its actually necessary to get some items.