Disagreed with you there. Why?
1-Renders aren't top-notch. There are many flaws. Especially when it comes to gravity. In addition to that, waist of females stays at mid air when they lie. This is unrealistic for me. My top-notch renderer is AWAM's dev. But Icstor is quite good.
2-Story.. This depends from person to person. I did like story quite a lot. Because it was unique.Why? Because, first time in an adult game, girls were trying to seduce MC except Caroline. (at least the ones i played)
3-Animations.. If you ask me to tell you top-3 animations, i would surely put Icstor into top-3. I don't think it is regular everyone's animations.
But there is one thing i agree with you.. Milfy City is not the best adult game here. But top5? Absouletely.
These are my personal opinions. Tastes can change from person to person. I do respect everyone's opinion. Peace.