Yes, Honey Select is normally terrible. It is much more like 4 out of 5 look bad or are the basic generic model unaltered. This MC model is probably on the better side of the basic models which there are a small handful. The games were made to have fun with female figures, so they didn't make it easy to alter males.
However we may have some good news on the way, end of May a new version comes out. Honey Select 2 Libido. So games may start using that, it has more realistic models the same silly sex actions though.
You must be registered to see the links
(if you can read japanese)
Supposedly around a week, but don't get your hopes up.
Back on topic. This MC isn't terrible, now he isn't the best character, but he has relatable stupid teenage moments.