He's surprisingly fit for how dweeby he looks, something I continually forget until his clothes come off for a scene. There's actually a new outfit in the upcoming update that accentuates that fact and I personally think it makes him look properly handsome.All that said, I think the MC still has above average looks, compared to many other third person VNs. I feel a lot less like I‘m in control of some unwashed, grimy creep than in other games.
The worst offenders are the games that are usually in first person but have to switch to third person to put a better perspective into the scene. That‘s when it shows that the creator did not put a lot of effort into the main character model.
I think Pale Carnations does it‘s job with the male models pretty well, given how limited the possibilities are.