sunaboz

Member
Donor
Jun 25, 2018
467
1,663
At the end of the last update, I didn't have the option "seek advice from Kathleen", did I miss some precondition?
At the end of 3.4, I don't have the option "seek kathleen for advice", does anyone know how to trigger this.:cry:
Kathleen option has been added in the previous update (a public one) but you might not have downloaded the updated one (this is why it's best to download from directly):

Since now you have the most recent version (for now) you can go back a save and you will have it.
 

bamachine

Well-Known Member
Nov 17, 2020
1,402
1,912
I guess I am on the Hana GF route now, just hope I can also keep Mina in there, have a throuple. Don't want to add relationships with anyone else, be nice to the Carnations, even help them, fuck them for the events but not get into a relationship other than maybe friends with benefits, if my two ladies allow such.
 

starkj

Active Member
May 17, 2022
611
829
I guess I am on the Hana GF route now, just hope I can also keep Mina in there, have a throuple. Don't want to add relationships with anyone else, be nice to the Carnations, even help them, fuck them for the events but not get into a relationship other than maybe friends with benefits, if my two ladies allow such.
I made a save there just in case because Hana says he's only hers outside of the job.
 

dolfe67

Forum Fanatic
Apr 25, 2020
5,000
13,881
The dev missed the oportunity to make some skill checks in this update, tireless and strong could fit some of those options, just to upset some people, of course, and give us more reasons to love our mods. 10 out 10 would fap again.
If the tireless and strong skills were to fit every sex scenes, it would be a no-brainer pick. Maybe the butterfly or social chameleon to make her call you daddy?

Hana is the perfect GF, she still want to be yours knowing what you do in the club (ultimately like porn stars's SO). And you want more?? What greedy players :BootyTime:
 
  • Haha
Reactions: RandyPhoenix

absalon1977

Active Member
Jun 5, 2018
957
616
Well there is definately a treesome with mina and hana in the future i would say thats almost confirmed with this update, there is only one question is it possible too get that on a hana gf route, the mc is allready thinking that it might be a good idea too tell hana the truth about mina we will probadly get the option too do that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ale3 and Motion11

Turret

Forum Fanatic
Jun 23, 2017
4,191
7,170
Hi, TD1900 , GIL3D and all the other PC players!

Here are some thoughts on the new update and Pale Carnations in general.

Renders: Absolute top, your game and "Eternum" are the peak of HS-based games here! The attention for details is great ( e.g. licence plates, computer screen images or fan T-shirts and real labels) and the micro-movements of the characters seal the deal. GIL´s very considerable talent for HS-stuff seems to have risen even higher over time, when comparing for example the early bike rides and the bike scenes now. Do you have changed from a heavily modified HS1 to a heavily modified Honey Select 2/AiS? Some scenes seem to indicate into this direction.

Story: No matter the path you are on, great writing of the story. Lots of small hints and evidence strategically tucked in(e.g.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
), very nice writing of sex and love scenes, harsh when it has to be and nice and cute when that is needed. Besides, like other members already said, very nice to see a game where "just" kissing and being close plays an important role.

Hana: Absolutely adorable tough girl and among the possible LIs for a nice or mischiveous MC the one with the most chemistry and shared traits and burdens. Like all other LIs very attractive (as I mentioned a while ago, this is great work by you two, since normally girls tattooed this heavily is a turn-off for me).
Nice that the new update confirmed my estimation on some character traits of Hana:
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Looking forward to how the choices we can make in this update influence the relations with Ian and August in special. There is a thawing between Hana and those two currently.

Character traits: Social Chameleon for the win! Enabled me to have the choice to go to Kathleen for advice, while playing a really nice Edwin with max relations with Hana and Ian, near max relations with Felicia and Rosi, high relations with Mina and Veronica and near current max relations with August, Chuck, Samson and Jacob.

Dr. Lundgren: We have not seen her too often currently, but I look forward to see if we can win her (and Abel) over to "our" side instead of Kath´s. Seems to be an eccentric character and I really love quirky and eccentric characters (e.g. Miru and Leia in "Where it all began")!
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Felicia: As with Sophia, Felicia is a contradictory person, mainly just lacking selfesteem. I really like her and see her as the most probable LI among the Carnations, followed by Rosi. Curious how the art exhibition evening will go, esp. if you went with her freely.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Mina: Our little bundle of sunshine is the inversion of Hana when it comes to sexual stuff it turn out over the run of the game. Whereas Hana
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

Ian: I doubt it spoilers much if directly writing that in the new update we finally can try to really help Ian getting his act together. And there are some hints toward some juicy possible paths in the future.
 

JenusKudo

Well-Known Member
Aug 4, 2017
1,392
922
When the time comes, having to choose between Mina and Hana will be a tough one... Or maybe when Hana's anger score is low enough she'll consider a ménage à trois with Mina :BootyTime:
Turning mina bi will help you in your ending... Without sufficient bi point, it's meaningless
 

GMDominance

Newbie
Mar 5, 2019
40
99
Turning mina bi will help you in your ending... Without sufficient bi point, it's meaningless
I know that, what I mean is in this update we know Mina doesn't mind another girl in the relationship, but Hana want full attention outside of the club and just want a normal relationship. So maybe if Hana's anger is low enough we can be on both Mina GF and Hana GF route? Pretty please :BootyTime:
 

starkj

Active Member
May 17, 2022
611
829
Turning mina bi will help you in your ending... Without sufficient bi point, it's meaningless
It's weird tho because in my playtrough, Mina doesnt have any bi points but she still mentions having a menage à trois with Hana :unsure:
 

bububananas

Newbie
Aug 12, 2019
51
305
2023-08-26: Updated to Chapter 4 Update 3

Gallery Unlocker - Chapter 4 Update 3
Extract contents into the main folder of the game. This only unlocks the gallery, it does nothing else (e.g. walk through).

Great game, but I hate grinding to unlock scenes, so here you go.
 
Last edited:

Stan5851

Engaged Member
Oct 18, 2019
3,089
6,405
Hi, respected developers TD1900, GIL3D and all active players. I'm a bit confused. Now Ch4 Up1 is out, but the changelog for the previous update Chapter 3 Update 4 Public mentions two fixed bugs, namely.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
In this regard, I have a question. I don't remember which build of Ch3Up4 I played six months ago, but at the end of Ch3 Up4 in my walkthrough, all three Carnations ended up with one vote each. So it was a draw, after which Caitlin said it was a kind of a loss for each of the Carnations and that a "penalty game" was waiting for each of them in the next week of the Exhibition.

How is this consistent with the fact that at the very beginning of Ch3 Up4 Caitlin announced to Felicia
Felicia_win.jpg and then Veronica veronica_win.jpg that they had won the audience vote? After all, according to this, at the end of Ch3 Up4, Felicia should have won (1 vote from Caitlin + 1 vote from the viewers judging the photoshoot contest) and Rosalind (1 vote from Hana) and Veronica (1 vote from the viewers for winning the photoshoot contest) should have lost. But in fact, we see a tie at the end of Ch3 Up4.

Am I right to understand that this is a bug and I have to rerun (via Ctrl) the "Ch3 Up4 Public" content before starting to play Ch4 Up1? Thanks.
 
Last edited:

Unreal434

Member
Sep 23, 2018
131
328
I wonder if you can get Hana as your girlfriend later on if you are passive during the date and no sex happens this update. :unsure:

Also there is quite a lot of people that want Mina-Hana threesome but speaking of possible threesomes I would much rather see Hana/Mina-Veronica or Mina-Felicia or perhaps Harper with any of the bi-curious girls. We still have the rain check from her after all.

I know its a subjective thing but for some reason girls of same age don´t do it for me as much as older girl with younger one in a threesome. Anyone else like that?
 
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: Nulldev
4.90 star(s) 498 Votes