This game is waaaay better than I thought it would be. wonder when I'll get my next dose of Carnation update
- Thread starter GIL3D
- Start date
-
- Tags
- 3dcg ahegao anal sex animated bdsm big ass big tits bukkake cheating creampie exhibitionism female domination groping group sex handjob humiliation lactation lesbian male domination male protagonist masturbation milf mobile game multiple penetration oral sex prostitution romance sex toys spanking teasing titfuck urination vaginal sex voyeurism
- Apr 26, 2017
- 13,481
- 20,252
If i recall correctly the developers themselves confirmed they were also potential love interests in this thread.
- Nov 11, 2022
- 2,920
- 9,205
I'm well aware of that. All I'm saying is that the story hasn't progressed to the point where any of the three carnations really is romantically involved with the PC. Rose fucks him because of the deal, Felicia because she wants to have fun and Veronica and the MC haven't really fucked at all as of yet.
Even with Mina it isn't really a romance so far, they are more friends with benefits right now. Although their relationship is a lot further progressed than with any of the three Carnations.
- Apr 25, 2020
- 5,001
- 13,891
There is different types of romance.
Rose fucks him because of the deal yes, but something more is brewing. Felicia wants to have fun but there are hints depending on your choices that she's falling in love with the MC. Veronica is the most reluctant but again something more can be built.
A LI for me is a romanceable character, be it right from the start or later in the story (some are slow burn)
- Nov 11, 2022
- 2,920
- 9,205
The original question was a bit more specific though. Right now you don't watch actual love interests get fucked by others. That might come later down the line potentially.
- Oct 13, 2016
- 3,592
- 7,558
well its up to the player what he want to call the girls.
I only see 2 LI, where only 1 is confirmed if u want while the other is more open and not a closed deal.
I think its good that we can not pick whatever, this is not a harem-game its about depravity, humiliation, dominance, submission etc. even with the LI its not just something vanilla, theres doors that can be open with both of them. it all depends if the DEV want it or he want to have some normalcy. with Mina theres no limits here, I mean, it can be really dirty, if the MC want to push her into that direction if we follow the narrative. with Hana Im not 100% sure how much u can push her, she will push back, maybe it depends how close the MC gets. some girls gets submissive if they accept the male and allow almost anything.
my "hope" is that I can start corruption them. as I posted before, not into any carnation-events, but private settings.
I only see 2 LI, where only 1 is confirmed if u want while the other is more open and not a closed deal.
I think its good that we can not pick whatever, this is not a harem-game its about depravity, humiliation, dominance, submission etc. even with the LI its not just something vanilla, theres doors that can be open with both of them. it all depends if the DEV want it or he want to have some normalcy. with Mina theres no limits here, I mean, it can be really dirty, if the MC want to push her into that direction if we follow the narrative. with Hana Im not 100% sure how much u can push her, she will push back, maybe it depends how close the MC gets. some girls gets submissive if they accept the male and allow almost anything.
my "hope" is that I can start corruption them. as I posted before, not into any carnation-events, but private settings.
Yes, yes... or at least the base game is safe, unofficial Android version might be dangerous. Personally I recommend installing JoiPlay
You must be registered to see the links
and the Ren'Py add-on, and then download the PC version of this game, which I can vouch is not dirty on the Android.
- Aug 3, 2017
- 1,560
- 6,047
Welp, my review that I put a lot of effort into and a bunch of my other posts elsewhere got mod nuked yet again, haha. It's demoralizing to participate on this site sometimes to be honest, but I still wanted to give the devs props for this game nevertheless since they deserve it. 
Put simply Pale Carnations really is a great game and I highly recommend it. The writing is excellent, visuals are beautifully rendered, characters are wonderfully three-dimensional, and choices are impactful with long-lasting consequences. Everyone should give it a try! Five stars out of five!
Edit: This post is on topic as it pertains to the game without hurting anyone nor does it mention a certain game within the game, lol. Thanks.
Put simply Pale Carnations really is a great game and I highly recommend it. The writing is excellent, visuals are beautifully rendered, characters are wonderfully three-dimensional, and choices are impactful with long-lasting consequences. Everyone should give it a try! Five stars out of five!
Edit: This post is on topic as it pertains to the game without hurting anyone nor does it mention a certain game within the game, lol. Thanks.
Last edited:
- Apr 29, 2023
- 1,542
- 1,704
I hope the Hana/GF decision will roll around again after the MC talks/does the Mina threesome. Seemed like there was almost a potential throuple (or more with Carnations, especially Felicia) developing. While it may not be a harem game, the MC does seem to have a magic tongue & dick, so it's not far off. (this is from only playing up to the beginning of Week 3)
Can't believe I put this game off for so long, just because I didn't vibe with the model style immediately. That concern goes away quickly.
Can't believe I put this game off for so long, just because I didn't vibe with the model style immediately. That concern goes away quickly.
- Feb 24, 2022
- 11
- 1
- Mar 25, 2021
- 10,906
- 23,871
I can't bring myself to choose any options that are even slightly mean to the women in this game
They will get my love, respect & kindness for the whole game.
They all deserve to be treated like the beautiful angels they are.
They will get my love, respect & kindness for the whole game.
They all deserve to be treated like the beautiful angels they are.
- Aug 3, 2017
- 1,560
- 6,047
I don't know, man... I think there're exceptions. Ngl, I kinda enjoyed giving the sadistic boss the ol' cattle prod on my first run and that look she shot back at the MC afterwards, lol.
That was a fond, memorial moment for me, hahaha.
Last edited:
- Apr 29, 2023
- 1,542
- 1,704
So, it seems like the endgame for the MC, especially if Kathleen can influence it, is for
Is that a common theory? I'm not sure what the point of it is for Kathleen, other than mustache twirling evil.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
Is that a common theory? I'm not sure what the point of it is for Kathleen, other than mustache twirling evil.
- Apr 29, 2023
- 1,542
- 1,704
Liked how Go and Chess were layered in to reinforce the politicking of the club. Especially when you consider that in Chess a pawn can become a queen. They're the MC for more than just being the audience introduction and insert, they get to choose something at critical moments. Very curious how this will play out.
You're saying nonsense, both last updates took 6 months to come up. So for more than a year, this hasn't been the case. Gil and TD are clearly not as productive as they were in the beginning.It is usually on a 3-4 months schedule. J
The Hana update (Ch4Up1) took three and a half months and the last one (Ch4Up2) was five and a half months.
Just mentioning that for posterity's sake and not disputing the spirit of it, as both GIL and I have been unhappy with the speed in-game days have been progressing. As an aside, Ch3Up4 did take six months, but the output there was insane. 600 more images than the next closest update. It more than justified the increase in time from Ch3Up3.
- Mar 24, 2020
- 43
- 79
I just replayed the game and went through that scene the other day. I love the cheeky fuckin' look on Edwin's face after he zaps her. Completely worth it.I kinda enjoyed giving the sadistic boss the ol' cattle prod on my first run and that look she shot back at the MC afterwards, lol.
There is literally a guy a couple of pages back who has been posting metrics on the renders/animations/story per week and has a comparison chart with previous updates.
https://f95zone.to/threads/pale-carnations-ch-4-update-2-public-mutt-jeff.50281/post-11140944
Updates may take shorter/longer amounts of time depending on the content but bitching about their productivity is unfair. What are your grounds for claiming they are not productive? You can see the numbers in the linked post and you can see it is consistent.