VN Ren'Py Pale Carnations [Ch. 4 Up 4 Public] [Mutt & Jeff]

[GinAnalgin]

Since I didn't go down the path of romance with Veronica and Rosalind. It turned out that I did not see any new content in this update. How embarrassing as hell. For so much time waiting for at least a small scene for other characters or for a different path, at least something would have happened, but nothing happened ...
And no, I’m lying, there was that terrible Alice (a strange name for an Asian). Somehow, surprisingly quickly, I forgot about her ...
So the claim is dropped. But still, quite sad this time, the author got an update.
And I would like to add that the plot and the story is of course good. But still, do not forget why such games are made in the first place and what their component still plays the main role.

 

[ANALSEX]

Even after using the mod my saves are broken

yea i tried opening my old save with and without the mod, nothing loads

Oh well, I can wait for few more days

Load a save from the start of the last chapter. That worked for me.

 

[techguy00]

I didn't touch the mod and I can't get any of my saves from last update to work. I guess I'll keep waiting and hope for a patch. I don't want to replay my multiple different path saves from the start.

 

[omega_rugal]

No Kathleen ?

 

[Brainfurt]

 

[Trasher2018]

Uff - ok, so without the muscle girl there isnt much content.

That was awfully short

 

[JackassJeff]

This update was pretty disappointing to say the least,I love this game and I have no problems with the devs focusing on certain characters each update,but I would have liked if there was at least more content in this update with the other main girls,dont even have to have sex in it just some more dialogue and bonding,I didn't go the veronica path nor Rosalind since they are mainly nice guy path if that makes sense but I follow The Mc embracing his sadistic side path so that automatically puts them out of the equation,Still loved the updated hairstyles for the mc(he seriously needed one).The only thing that bothers me is that out of all the side girls the devs decided to give a scene in this update besides veronica and Rosalind is alice(Ian's maid which all scenes involved with her is just him having sex with her while the mc watches) Guess all of us who aint on veronica and Rosie's path going to have to wait even longer for new content.

 

[Shubhamdt98]

Can anyone share the save file till chapter 4 upadte 2 please

 

[BrockLanders]

i will recomend to have a save, maybe not for every girl, but 1 for every carnation, i for example have 3 saves, one were i go for Veronica and harem path for Mina and Hanna, then another one were i go for the Felicia and Mina, and finally one for Rosalind and Hanna.

Trying to cover my bases, I have a bunch of saves lol
Hana - CrPie
Hana Only
Mina Only
Felicia Only
Rose 3WayKil
Rose Only
Ronnie Only
Kathleen+ (I can fix her)
HanaMinaKath
Kath + RoseFD
Mina NoCheat

 

[Elduriel]

pretty good update, Veronica date was awesome. I have a Hana GF save as well, so it was interesting to see the other branch with the cute girl, Veronica will destroy her It's too bad you didn't get much with Hana this update but well, not all of them can be about her. Poor Rosalind also can't catch a break, and I'm curious what happens now that she is shacking up with MC... previously she wasn't against to have some fun. Also nice haircut

 

[sunaboz]

Another great update (not as good as previous one but it's no surprise since I consider it the best of all) with many memorable scenes/images.

Animations made by GIL seemed the best yet, e.g. Veronica swinging her ass was hypnotising (and I'm not into her), same goes for that braided girl in a purple skirt. Seeing Alice squirm and being fucked on camera was also very enjoyable (although that king line was a bit too much if you ask me) plus we have another potential threesome scene (I have faith in GIL that he will make it tasteful).

Ian seeing Veronica's tits and her response to a foursome was hilarious but that wasn't the funniest scene IMO. The one that cracked me up the most was the scene where Edwin asked Brit "You're not a-curious too, are you?", LMAO. But there were more funny scenes which I really appreciate.

But the high point of the update for me was the Olivier scene and ways we could handle it. IMO it was the best non-lewd scene in the whole game (and one of the best overall). It had tension, it had realism and it has shown us known characters in a very unusual situation (even for them) which made it really interesting and enjoyable.

BTW, I found it funny that Mina being supposedly younger Felicia didn't think about sex over phone but Hana did. Either way, both scenes are worth playing through (Alice scene too of course and it's my default one, although Hana scene was super hot and is a prelude to some really juicy one in the future).

Anyway, great work as always TD and GIL, I can't imagine a better duo for porn games. Which reminds me, that Mutt and Jeff reference was really well done, just like the whole update..

Spoiler: Some memorable scenes

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[Elduriel]

Trying to cover my bases, I have a bunch of saves lol
Hana - CrPie
Hana Only
Mina Only
Felicia Only
Rose 3WayKil
Rose Only
Ronnie Only
Kathleen+ (I can fix her)
HanaMinaKath
Kath + RoseFD
Mina NoCheat

that seems a bit excessive no? I mean in my view so far there are only two saves that are needed. One for Hana GF where you don't wanna cheat on her (outside the club)... but it locks out a lot of the content, and one where you are just fuckbuddies with her and you can get with any girl you want. This way you can see all content.

 

[sunaboz]

(...) This way you can see all content.

No you can't, you won't see what happens when they tie in the exhibition for example and you won't see content for Rosalind when you make a deal with her but there's more. In fact as of now whether you're fuckbuddies or something more doesn't change much and you can unlock exact same scenes.

 

[Yaaai]

Are there scenes with Hana or Mina?

 

[BrockLanders]

that seems a bit excessive no? I mean in my view so far there are only two saves that are needed. One for Hana GF where you don't wanna cheat on her (outside the club)... but it locks out a lot of the content, and one where you are just fuckbuddies with her and you can get with any girl you want. This way you can see all content.

Oh, absolutely it is excessive. Like I said, I'm trying to cover all the bases. When you get through that many playthroughs, and you're fast-forwarding a lot, it's interesting for me to see all the little nuanced dialogue changes... holding down Ctrl key and then it surprisingly pauses on a line of dialogue I didn't see yet. This really is very well written. Most people that read this VN aren't going to care about these little differences, but I like having the different saves that force me to focus completely on ways to play I wouldn't try otherwise. Who knows, maybe the full deal save is more evil than the all-in-on-Kathleen one? Maybe I'll be ready if TD adds the harem tag for the bubbly/goth sandwich? One day I'll find out!

I'm going to start reading the update today, I can't wait to see what happens.

 

[Elduriel]

No you can't, you won't see what happens when they tie in the exhibition for example and you won't see content for Rosalind when you make a deal with her but there's more. In fact as of now whether you're fuckbuddies or something more doesn't change much and you can unlock exact same scenes.

well of course you can unlock those scenes if you want to but then you are cheating on your girlfriend... I meant it more as a soft lock, you still get the option so it's up to you what you do, but if you decide to cheat on her why ask her to be your GF in the first place.

 

[captcha69]

This update was pretty disappointing to say the least,I love this game and I have no problems with the devs focusing on certain characters each update,but I would have liked if there was at least more content in this update with the other main girls,dont even have to have sex in it just some more dialogue and bonding,I didn't go the veronica path nor Rosalind since they are mainly nice guy path if that makes sense but I follow The Mc embracing his sadistic side path so that automatically puts them out of the equation,Still loved the updated hairstyles for the mc(he seriously needed one).The only thing that bothers me is that out of all the side girls the devs decided to give a scene in this update besides veronica and Rosalind is alice(Ian's maid which all scenes involved with her is just him having sex with her while the mc watches) Guess all of us who aint on veronica and Rosie's path going to have to wait even longer for new content.

there is MC´s mom too, a smal animation actually, but i think u need to be on Rosalind complete deal path, wich makes me wonder why u dont play that path, since u want to play the more sadistic version of MC... anyway if u ask Rosalind to clean ur semen out of the table with her mounth, u get a flash back of MC mom being fked silly. Wich again, weird, cause u can only get this scene IF u are not playing veronica´s path, and if u have the complete deal with Rosalind, so is very easy to miss.

 

[NukaCola]

Is this update worth playing if I'm not on Veronica or Rosalind path? I mean I did fuck them and everything but nothing romantically.

 

[JackassJeff]

there is MC´s mom too, a smal animation actually, but i think u need to be on Rosalind complete deal path, wich makes me wonder why u dont play that path, since u want to play the more sadistic version of MC... anyway if u ask Rosalind to clean ur semen out of the table with her mounth, u get a flash back of MC mom being fked silly. Wich again, weird, cause u can only get this scene IF u are not playing veronica´s path, and if u have the complete deal with Rosalind, so is very easy to miss.

Oh really?Thats something I missed then,
In my playthrough:
1.im dating Hana(Haven't rejected Mina offer tho so the mc is banging both of them,I made a save just in case something bad happens and Hana finds out and the relationship gets ruined so I can just go back and reject mina.Really hope that doesn't happen as me and alot of other people want to see The Mc have a threesome with those 2)
2.Veronica and Rosalind I missed all the options to romance them my stats with them are pretty low since I treated rose roughly and mostly agreed with Kathleen during the exhibition and anything related to it when involved with those 2 plus I guess my stats where too low so I didn't get the hug veronica during the exhibition,but I used a wt mod to help me balance out the Relationship points while still following through on being the sadistic Edwin. I don't know how I missed being able to make a deal with Rose(Maybe it was about the money problem idk) but I saw the option blanked out when she was at the mc home staying over.
3.For Felicia I agreed to go to the gallery with her but not as a paid relationship so we are kinda fuck buddies i guess.
So technically out of the main girls the paths I am on are:Mina,Hana,Felicia,Kathleen(I guess don't know yet since they fuck around and I have a high trust with her) and im not on any kind of relationship with Veronica and Rose.

 

[JackassJeff]

Is this update worth playing if I'm not on Veronica or Rosalind path? I mean I did fuck them and everything but nothing romantically.

You will have to wait for the next update since majority of this update is veronica and near the end has a rose scene,Since I don't follow either the update took me around 10 minutes to complete,it was mostly dialogue and an Alice sex scene with Ian(I checked the scenes and saw their is a Hana scene as well dont know if its for the fuck buddies path or not I will check it out if so.)