TD1900

#701
Game Developer
Dec 8, 2017
744
6,559
Ok, so i get i'm just being silly cause playing the game will obviously explain things to me but i'm impatient and want to know, given the game is about a brothel, i searched for ntr/sharing and got a lot of responses that said 'nope' and that's cool, i could play with or without it depending on the quality of the game, i don't mind going outside my personal tastes for a good story, but now i'm left wondering how you can not have ntr with a game about brothel girls, aren't they boning clients every night? How's it actually work? I'm not an ntr guy but i'm not at all militant about it and i can still get into a story where the LI's are working girls if that's what they are, could be very interesting, but yeah, i guess i just don't know what this game actually is and want to know how i should be expecting things to go.
The titular Carnations are part of a yearly show where the club takes "normal" women, promises to reward one of them, pits them against each other to see who can become the most star-studded whore. The MC is the ringleader's lackey and stunt dick, although, some of the events have involved other patrons and the MC's best friend.

The game doesn't contain NTR by virtue of the game's setting and the main character's disposition. The story isn't centered around having a loved one stolen from you. The main character isn't in a committed relationship with any of the Carnations, nor does he entertain any notion of monogamy with them in the present circumstances.

Now, will you feel sad about what's happening to them? Maybe. Hopefully.
Because that means I succeeded in making the characters worthy of empathy.

There's also a lot of weird shit involving the MC's mom, but that's at the forefront of everything, so you should know pretty quickly if that's a deal breaker or not.
 

Bingoogus

Engaged Member
Sep 5, 2021
2,825
6,616
All I can say is this game is really different from just about any I have ever played. Here your decisions are basically become a super jerk or fake being a super jerk and actually be a nice guy underneath it all. so, it's difficult to answer your question but basically several of the girls can become actual LI's I guess that's why there could be possible NTR but they also work in a brothel so to speak as you say. So all in all it's not traditional ntr but there are scenes that can make some people uncomfortable because there are several options that I don't want to spoil for you but you will basically see others having their fun at times. So imo there is no definitive answer to your question as it's a matter of perspective. I personally am not a fan of NTR at all but I do enjoy this game there are some scenes I don't care for but I knew that was a possiblity when I started so I just tried to go with the choices that I wanted and not any preset or pre determined outcomes if you will. I tried to make my choices fit the moment. I know that's not very helpful probably but I would suggest giving it a try and see what you think...
The titular Carnations are part of a yearly show where the club takes "normal" women, promises to reward one of them, pits them against each other to see who can become the most star-studded whore. The MC is the ringleader's lackey and stunt dick, although, some of the events have involved other patrons and the MC's best friend.

The game doesn't contain NTR by virtue of the game's setting and the main character's disposition. The story isn't centered around having a loved one stolen from you. The main character isn't in a committed relationship with any of the Carnations, nor does he entertain any notion of monogamy with them in the present circumstances.

Now, will you feel sad about what's happening to them? Maybe. Hopefully.
Because that means I succeeded in making the characters worthy of empathy.

There's also a lot of weird shit involving the MC's mom, but that's at the forefront of everything, so you should know pretty quickly if that's a deal breaker or not.
awda.png
Hmmm... Interesting.
 

techguy00

Newbie
May 3, 2021
38
38
Don't have a single clue about renpy, but I've heard that problem may be caused by using another mod previously. Modders come and go plus because we see updates rarely I have no idea what mod I've been using myself. Can't load any saves too. There's one very kind and generous modder on these forums but I just can't ask him to help, because I think he would've, although we aren't acquintances, only because he's a good guy.

I've never modded the game and my saves from chapter 2 do not work. Saves earlier than do seem to work.

The only things I can think of that I changed is using renhack to extract the rpa files so I could read the script as a walkthru so I don't miss any scenes. I can't imagine how that would break anything.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 

techguy00

Newbie
May 3, 2021
38
38
I've never modded the game and my saves from chapter 2 do not work. Saves earlier than do seem to work.

The only things I can think of that I changed is using renhack to extract the rpa files so I could read the script as a walkthru so I don't miss any scenes. I can't imagine how that would break anything.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
I did some more testing. I had multiple up2 saves other than the masters I was trying to load. It seemed that most of them worked. It seems like only the ones that saved one the end of chapter message failed, which I don't think has been an issue with this game in past versions. I also tried loading those master saves in the up2 version of the game and rolling them back, this still would not allow them to load. But loading saves from during the up2 Mina sex scenes and the very begining of the confrontation with Abel worked.

Hope this helps other and/or the devs figuring out what triggered this so they can avoid it in future.

EDIT:

Oh another interesting note. When I loaded those master saves in up2 and rolled back, both my crashing masters when rolled back skipped the final scene with the MC's mom for some reason. I'm pretty sure I remember seeing that scene when I played it so I can't explain this.
 

MorbidViews21

Active Member
Aug 3, 2019
506
952
what variable do i need to change to have the date with veronica? I thought i did everything right with her lol. She won't go out for drinks with me. It said you need to hug her? but their is no hug variable.
 

longjohngold

Well-Known Member
Jan 22, 2020
1,112
1,767
Okay so as this update was focused around Ol' Ronnie I've been having a think about a way for her to end up being permanently tied to the club, but in a happy nice way, as I'm desperate for a Veronica Fel throuple wifey situation (as unlikely as that may be).

I think maybe it could be solved by the club using her gym to launder money. She'd still get to be all mega intense about the gym so it'd only attract a few clients but ones that share her very hardcore attitude, but it'd no longer matter if it was a viable business or not. Only problem is I'm not even sure if the club would need that, as they can probably account for all the money by being a fancypants elitist institution, and just not mentioning the whores. The only other way I could see it would be to have all the prostitutes attend her gym to keep them in shape, or let the gym fold by have Veronica set one up for the girls inhouse, but that doesn't seem as neat and tidy.

The Fel part is easy, use the clubs connections to fuck over her husband somehow so she can divorce him and take all his money regardless of wat kind of prenup there was. She'd then buy out Kathleen's share to become the queen of the club. As while I really like Kathleen I've never forgiven her for saying the MC can't get her pregnant any more (the only less sexy thing than that would be to say she doesn't want it). So I dunno what to do with her, as I want her killer mind intact but somehow hopped up on aphrodisiacs and cock addicted so she becomes the head girl and uses all her wit to get the only thing she now cares about might work.

MC just needs to inherit Chuck's share having somehow pushed Killian aside. Previously I wanted to knock up Mina then have Chuck ban him from the club to focus being on a father, but I guess that'd not work now. Though I do want to get Mina working at the club asap and then get to see Killian's reaction when he sees her slobbering over a few old men's dicks... so I'll need to keep him around long enough for that.

Hana would inherit August's share maybe when he gets killed in some kinda dirty business. Kathleen would then be rightly concerned how her goody goody attitude would mess with the club and so would find some way to mindbreak her with those drugs and keep her as the bartender but also a house girl making her share a silent partner. This'd be prior to the MC then in turn doing basically the same to Kathleen as previously mentioned, having learned it from her while helping do it to Hana.

No interest in Rose really other than as a conduit to seeing the mother doing porn, and I'd rather go to the source for that. I imagine some kinda scenario near the end when she falls on hard times again and the MC has the choice to now either sell the share of the club he's gotten from chuck to stop her spreading her legs on camera again, following a normal life, and becoming a doctor... or maybe by this point he's so deep in it he lets it happen so he doesn't have to sacrifice his club action. It'd be interesting to see if he hates it, gets off on it, or even tries to take things over and make her do some blindfolded scenes where he's the stuntcock without her knowing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TD1900

RC-1138 Boss

Message Maven
Apr 26, 2017
13,043
19,298
what variable do i need to change to have the date with veronica? I thought i did everything right with her lol. She won't go out for drinks with me. It said you need to hug her? but their is no hug variable.
You need to raise Veronica's friendship score high enough to get the choice for Edwin to hug her after Kathleen pretty much rapes her.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MorbidViews21

longjohngold

Well-Known Member
Jan 22, 2020
1,112
1,767
what variable do i need to change to have the date with veronica? I thought i did everything right with her lol. She won't go out for drinks with me. It said you need to hug her? but their is no hug variable.
You need to have this 1693093217026.png

She'll say no, but then call up later to invite the MC, so I presume it's the "veronicaFriend" flag... there was a choice ages ago when she was crying and naked where you could hug her and say you wanted to be her friend.

Edit: Yeah is splits slightly earlier in the convo when MC says something about how she's making it hard work for just a how are you... 1693093435331.png
 

MorbidViews21

Active Member
Aug 3, 2019
506
952
You need to have this View attachment 2881694

She'll say no, but then call up later to invite the MC, so I presume it's the "veronicaFriend" flag... there was a choice ages ago when she was crying and naked where you could hug her and say you wanted to be her friend.
yeah i did have that, but she said no. Oh i guess i have to keep playing, i thought she was suppose to say yes right there. Gotcha thanks.
 

Alfius

Engaged Member
Modder
Sep 30, 2017
2,223
4,606
All I can say is this game is really different from just about any I have ever played. Here your decisions are basically become a super jerk or fake being a super jerk and actually be a nice guy underneath it all. so, it's difficult to answer your question but basically several of the girls can become actual LI's I guess that's why there could be possible NTR but they also work in a brothel so to speak as you say. So all in all it's not traditional ntr but there are scenes that can make some people uncomfortable because there are several options that I don't want to spoil for you but you will basically see others having their fun at times. So imo there is no definitive answer to your question as it's a matter of perspective. I personally am not a fan of NTR at all but I do enjoy this game there are some scenes I don't care for but I knew that was a possiblity when I started so I just tried to go with the choices that I wanted and not any preset or pre determined outcomes if you will. I tried to make my choices fit the moment. I know that's not very helpful probably but I would suggest giving it a try and see what you think...
Edit: Ok so above instead of LI's I should say something more like friendly fuck buddies or something. Beyond that not sure. There is one carnation I really like though so maybe in the future we will get a chance to see if there could be something more to it but I'm not the dev so... he says they are just contestants then who knows what the future holds.
Let you give me my take on this.

There are just 2 main girls that are possible love interest and not working as a prostitute or a carnation girl. There are other girls as well, like your boss and other minor characters, but they are not possible love interest.

Of that 2 love interest, one is currently in a relationship and are having sex offscreen. The other one is currently not attached to anyone.

If the of the 3 main carnation girls 1 is married and can have onscreen sex depending on your choice, one can have on screen sex depending on your choice and the other one, is relatively untouched at this stage (Except if you count lesbian action as NTR)

You can get attached to some of the other girls as well, but they are prostitutes and definitely have sex with other men (Most off screen, but some on screen)

So to answer you question. It is not an NTR focused game. But it is in a brothel setting and lots of other men have sex with girls you might like.

Having said that, the girls you can pursue into some kind of relationship (not just sex) at this stage, once in a relationship does not cheat on you.
 
  • Thinking Face
Reactions: Bingoogus
Dec 5, 2021
57
414
Another update, another opportunity to savour the relationships in the story. I do have to say that the scenes away from the exhibitions, and the ones that are club adjacent rather than the club situate, are my favourite, and so both this update and the previous update were quite welcome.

As always, the presentation and visual quality of the game just continue to improve and excel. In trying to catch all my saves up to speed (there are now 38 pages of them at various junctures for the various paths), I ran a few saves from the early days to the present, and the improvements to an already visually well-defined product was nothing short of remarkable. A fair few of the visual shortcomings from the first few chapters, such as overly pale skin on certain characters and the relative lack of details in the male cast due to HS restraints, have now all been smoothed over. One observation I made was that I can now actually buy into the idea somewhat that Ian's as good looking as the characters in the game make him out to be.

The texture of skin, the detail in their hair, these little things that build up over time culminated in me being almost startled when we call Felicia to check up on her and the camera zooms in to show a beautiful profile of the blonde in her bikini. The way the gold and yellow colours of her outfit and hair worked off of each other with the lighting, especially the flowing strands of Felicia's hair, *chef's kiss, looked simply phenomenal. I honestly am amazed that GIL is able to get these sorts of results from the HS engine and continues to push the limits on a relatively dated character creator (RIP Illusion).

Ian and MC's new hairstyles were also quite refreshing, though I will miss how perfectly his previous hairstyle matched the dweeb persona that I've embraced. I could see MC's hair working especially well to give Patrick Bateman style slimey vibes in a more sadistic playthrough. I think him freshening up and meeting Veronica also caught her by surprise with how well put together he looked, but I'll have more to say when I talk about her scenes specifically.


You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.


You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.


You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

It was another thoroughly great update, even if I'm not the biggest Veronica enjoyer. I do think that there was also plenty of other content and progressed several plot points, and has whet my appetite for the next update.

Kudos TD and GIL, in a world where many great AVNs that I follow on this site have plateaued or saw slight dips in quality, Pale Carnations keeps on delivering.
 
Last edited:

bamachine

Well-Known Member
Nov 17, 2020
1,343
1,812
Really liked this update, brought me closer to understanding Ian, Rosalind and Veronica(played both options at the end, will stick with the one where we spend far more time with her, the other seems almost throwaway or for the more cold-hearted).
 

Bingoogus

Engaged Member
Sep 5, 2021
2,825
6,616
So i did a search and it's clear this game is not going for incest with the mom. But, given that she's there, she's made very lovable and we're made to feeeel for her... why isn't incest on the table? Like, is it just a personal preference thing or simply not what this story is about or is it just cause it keeps Patreon of your back? I want mommy dearest to be well taken care of, have all her needs fulfilled but there's no dude in the game that i've seen so far that would be 'good enough' for her in my eyes... oh god, i just realised, she doesn't get involved with the club does she? Or like, the service side of it? That'd be too awful to keep playing...
 

Lunarmist

Darkness of The Mist
Uploader
Compressor
Feb 5, 2022
969
7,013
Don't have a single clue about renpy, but I've heard that problem may be caused by using another mod previously. Modders come and go plus because we see updates rarely I have no idea what mod I've been using myself. Can't load any saves too. There's one very kind and generous modder on these forums but I just can't ask him to help, because I think he would've, although we aren't acquintances, only because he's a good guy.
The problem is the mod worked for a random save I found here, most of the broken saves also don't work on the fresh install of the game.
 

somebody28

Member
Mar 10, 2018
142
150
TD1900 Damn it man, I can't tell if I want to go through with fucking Veronica or not. On the one hand, the game and dialogue kept telling me over and over not too.

On the other hand, the scenes are just so freaking hot. And the pool talk about shotput was awesome.

On the other other hand, all the talk of Veronica being a 'conquest' really struck close to home. I'm a sucker for when video game characters get to participate in the conversation about their role in the story.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: ename144
4.90 star(s) 474 Votes