Thank you for the clarification. In that case, I don't think you should make her pregnant. It's a very polarizing fetish and I have never seen anyone on the fence about it that's thought about it for more than five minutes. Luxee decided to "force" it in PL with a character after saying it would be an option and is getting flak for it.
well to be honest i haven't seen a single game where there isn't anyone complaining really. either it's about niche fetishes/kinks someone is just not into or it's about the story in gerneral. look at my sister, my roommate. sumodeine is continuing the story because of how unhappy the majority was with how he ended his story. this is another topic tho.
what i really don't understand is the complaints about kinks. as soon as there is ntr people complain for example. i get it really but then why you download a game with the ntr tag? or forgotten paradise. the tags say footjob and then someone comes along and complains mimimi i get you have a foot fetish but don't rub it in our face like that because for everyone without a foot fetish it's just disgusting and the biggest turn off. i get that however the tags tell people what they are up for and as far as i remember all those scenes were even optional. then just don't download the game i would say? it's like a vegetarian ordering a steak and then complaining it's meat really.
my point really is no matter what fetishes the game is about there will always be those who like it if they are into it and those who will hate it. there is no way to make everyone happy without blowing up a game beyond imagination and without creating the most insane clusterfuck of branches. in german we have a saying: a compromise is perfect once noone is satisfied.
or as i always say: my cat likes mice. i don't.
these really sum up how i feel about those niche fetishes in these games. the devs should just go for what they imagine the games and stories to be. if they avoid every rare kink then people will complain that it's just a game like thousand others. if it contains those fetishes then people will complain because they are just not into it. but i suppose that's what "niche" means isn't it?