- Sep 26, 2019
- 7,511
- 14,647
- Thread starter Crazygamer43
- Start date
- Mar 8, 2019
- 484
- 578
I think the mc will always have in the back of his mind (depending on where he lives) many states have a law that if you were ever caretaker or "in loco parentis" that person is legally speaking off limits to you forever. That being said as long as the girls are on board and no one films anything, he's cool. the state can't prove anything, but that doesn't mean he won't worry about shannon finding out, after all she is already pissed about divorce settlement and won't be any happier if she finds out about the will... she will do whatever she can to screw him once her daughters leave her for him. all she needs do is make the acusation and the authorities must investigate even if only cursorily. That can be a problem, one bedrooom for both him and abbey ... step daughters living a few doors down???
Oh yeah i totally get this and in fact like this aspect of it. Most games dont try to make it seem a bit more realistic which sucks
Im all for making it more realistic, believable BUT there is a good way of doing it, a bad way of doing it and then there is the OVERKILL way of doing it (its still a bad way of doing it). I think we can all guess which way this went.
If this was done better, this would have been probably one of my favorite games (almost ... i dont like the art style .... whats with Beth for example? She looks like a zombie ... also Abby looks weird sometimes)
As I've mentioned earlier in the thread. Once both parties are of legal age there is no state in the USA which has any laws preventing intimate sexual contact between step relations. They can marry in all states excepting Virginia.
(unrelated to the discussion above, sorry)
oh for fuck sake ... now he's complaining for the gift they got from the lawyer ... COME ON DUDE, take a pill, chill!!
This is so frustrating haha
oh for fuck sake ... now he's complaining for the gift they got from the lawyer ... COME ON DUDE, take a pill, chill!!
This is so frustrating haha
- May 9, 2018
- 2,490
- 6,858
Bummer. There really is no need for side stories for all the girls. Either the story is important enough to make it into the main game or it's not worth taking time away from the main story to waste on side stories.
With all the activity on this thread lately I'm beginning to feel like I missed out on an update or something.
Chapter 1 was all about him getting over his hang ups with Lilly and Becca. He has now got past that when he set boundaries with Lilly (which does include when they can be together) and made the decision to sleep with Becca. His internal struggle with them is dealt with. The only conflict is Abby because he doesn't want to do anything to lose her. He still isn't over losing Jessica and Abby is the closest thing he has to her. Its hard for him because he is a good father, even though technically he isn't related to any of them. Chapter 2 starts the day after he slept with Becca and she told him she wants them all to be his wives. There is a massive step between thinking of someone as a daughter to thinking of them as your wife. Frank is basically being groomed by Becca at this point.
"Sorry about my sister killing your soul mate and not caring about killing her, here is some cash." Wouldn't you be pissed at that? I know I would. Your partner's life had a price tag?
Not necessarily. The story is told from Frank's perspective, it is his narrative. He isn't around for the girls all the time. The side stories give us the girl's perspective. It would be weird to shift who is telling the story for a long section. Lilly's side story was all to do with her thoughts and feelings. That is why she got a side story. I'm not saying we need a side story for Mei, or Beth or anyone else, but the main trio, yeah, I want to explore their thoughts and feelings.
- Apr 2, 2020
- 750
- 995
- May 9, 2018
- 2,490
- 6,858
I agree that the story is shown from Franks perspective so it would have been hard to show it from Lilly's. Maybe I'm just too hung up on the 3 letter tag which is what that whole side story was for me. I could see the point showing her change and thoughts and feelings, but then there is no need to show her fucking her ex's. Putting in those scenes negated any good the side story did. It sucks because Lilly is my favourite of the lot, but I felt screwed if I played the side story and screwed if I didn't because stuff in the main story doesn't make as much sense.
The only thing I'll concede is it makes sense with Lilly because it's such a dramatic shift in her, from vocally hating him to riding him almost over night. The other girls don't have that drama or need for explanation. Becca's already explained to him that she's had the hots for him for years, almost since he married Shannon if I recall. Abby too has made her feeling pretty obvious. There is no need to show or explain them further.
Again the dev time could be better spent in my opinion at least progressing the story and progressing the character change in Frank so there is less hand ringing than showing Becca's thoughts or feelings, which she's made abundantly clear.
After a review of incest laws and "void or fictitious marriages" by states, over half of the states in the US indicate "step" as a prohibited relationship for sexual conduct. Most of the laws do not specify that the law only applies to minors but age 16 and above which would include this situation. That considered... the MC has every right to worry about legal ramifications and the fact that the girls are over 18 is irrelevant. That aside, as long as they are all consenting adults and keep the activities and relationships in the house, even if the ex-wife gets suspicious and causes an investigation, if there isn't any proof and none of the girls admit, they won't get into trouble. However, I would immediately delete all inappropriate messages between all of them on their phones such as the pictures and direct statements as they could be used as evidence if anyone got a subpoena for the records.
Oh? Okay. Find me the law. Because I looked at all the states before I made my post. If you read the law you'll find that it doesn't apply to relations between legal adults. You are correct that the law is to protect minors, but various court decisions make it clear that step adults can do as they please.
My reasoning is partially timing (Abbys side story is in production), but mostly that there is a Lilly problem, and the most obvious way to solve it is if Abby catches Frank and Lilly in flagrante, which I think would make a nice mirror to "You're a dead man Frank"
I'm looking for a link to the law. Because I am certain that in the case where both parties are adults and it is a step relationship you are incorrect.
You must be registered to see the links
This is a state by state account for incest laws. It shows the specific law for each state and a brief overview allowing for further research into exact terms and situations. The first state, Alabama, indicates that a relationship, to include a sexual activity, with a stepchild or stepparent is considered incest. It does not indicate any age limits meaning even adults apply. Also, I have personal knowledge of Las Vegas, Nevada having such laws as a person I knew is currently in prison as it is a felony due to having a relationship with his stepdaughter and both were adults. Again, not all states have the step clause and some specify if someone is under a certain age, but there are laws. Feel free to review the document I linked as it was a great reference source.