- Jun 12, 2017
- 9,840
- 129,703
This master piece, combines the best of both games
View attachment 1616219
Piracy is piracy and theft is theft, they're two different things. Everyone downloads and patches Adobe software, seeing as they care more about the billions, they make annually via subscription from big companies than regular people. Stealing anyone's art, regardless of it being 'premade assets from a store that you click and render' (obviously not true, but many seem to be under that impression about Daz.) or not, is still theft. He isn't downloading a program, he's stealing other people's artwork and claiming it as his own.It leaves a bit of bad taste using the renders from other creators/games and then monetize it. Can't really do the holier than thou on someone when they pirate on a site dedicated to piracy though.
That would be the least of it's problems, similar models appearing in new games is nothing new, the Carli from Depraved Awakening is everywhere, the niece from Babysitters... similar face different hair i don't even count anymore.The character model is the same as in the game Inside Jennifer
And when you pirate the same dudes work... that isn't theft? You not stealing his work to entertain yourself? Sure, its two different things, but both criminal... So to try take a morale high ground is pointless.Piracy is piracy and theft is theft, they're two different things. Everyone downloads and patches Adobe software, seeing as they care more about the billions, they make annually via subscription from big companies than regular people. Stealing anyone's art, regardless of it being 'premade assets from a store that you click and render' (obviously not true, but many seem to be under that impression about Daz.) or not, is still theft. He isn't downloading a program, he's stealing other people's artwork and claiming it as his own.
To be fair they "give credit" to the other games on the itch.io page but it is still very shady. They are trying to make money off of others work. Everyone knows the most time consuming and labor intensive part of an AVN especially using Daz is the renders. They are only doing the writing, poorly in my opinion, and getting a free worker from whatever game they decide to unren next. If anything it's much closer to plagiarism than piracy.Piracy is piracy and theft is theft, they're two different things. Everyone downloads and patches Adobe software, seeing as they care more about the billions, they make annually via subscription from big companies than regular people. Stealing anyone's art, regardless of it being 'premade assets from a store that you click and render' (obviously not true, but many seem to be under that impression about Daz.) or not, is still theft. He isn't downloading a program, he's stealing other people's artwork and claiming it as his own.
There is worse out there. There is those that just steal the entire thing and rewrap it as their own work and put it up for sale on websites.. with no credit given to original creators what so ever. Which happens because very few if any at all of these creators want to pursue legal actions, as that is a costly process.To be fair they "give credit" to the other games on the itch.io page but it is still very shady. They are trying to make money off of others work. Everyone knows the most time consuming and labor intensive part of an AVN especially using Daz is the renders. They are only doing the writing, poorly in my opinion, and getting a free worker from whatever game they decide to unren next. If anything it's much closer to plagiarism than piracy.
I'm all for piracy. Hence why I upload my own VN here for free a week after anyone who financially supports the project has gotten it. Fuck Adobe and their subscription services. Same goes for anything of that sort. But I do have a problem with people who consciously steal shit, make a profit from something they didn't make, and then advertise it as their own intellectual property. Hiding and/or putting attribution to the original games in small print just as grimy. He could've just as easily put it in the overview/summary.And when you pirate the same dudes work... that isn't theft? You not stealing his work to entertain yourself? Sure, its two different things, but both criminal... So to try take a morale high ground is pointless
Just saying both is a crime (Illegal), so in a place such as this, it would be like one crook pointing a finger at another and claim they are the bigger one. The creator is pirating though, because he pirate the gfx assets of someone else. He use them in a transformative work, so its not directly plagiarism. It doesn't excuse him of what he did, or give someone credits for the assets doesn't make it right either unless he got a green light from the creators to use said assets.I'm all for piracy. Hence why I upload my own VN here for free a week after anyone who financially supports the project has gotten it. Fuck Adobe and their subscription services. Same goes for anything of that sort. But I do have a problem with people who consciously steal shit, make a profit from something they didn't make, and then advertise it as their own intellectual property. Hiding and/or putting attribution to the original games in small print just as grimy. He could've just as easily put it in the overview/summary.
I'm not taking any ground, just calling it what it is. Once again - Piracy and theft/plagiarism are two different things, and legally, are treated as such. The reality is that an overwhelming majority of developers willingly upload their VN/game/projects here as the sheer size of F95's userbase allows them to get a ton of eyes on them. In that sense, F95 has become and is basically a more of a free, non-F2P, dev-friendly (in most cases, at least) Nutaku. Reddit is dead, Twitter is slow-growing, DeviantArt stopped being relevant years ago. Whereas F95 has 10,000+ users online at any given time. It's quid pro quo; make a good game/VN and the financial support will come more often than not. Most likely from this forum.
Plagiarism - using someone else's ideas or words without crediting the source and pretending they're your own. No, crediting the developer's renders isn't proper attribution. Especially when you're (attempting) to make a profit like said dev. Is he using other dev's renders without permission? Yes. Is he incorrectly attributing the games and their devs/authors? Yes. Hell, he probably UnRen'd someone's VN and copy-pasted his code.
Piracy - the unauthorized use, reproduction, or sharing of copyrighted or patented material – typically music, movies, TV shows, and software. Are we pirating his music/movies? No. Are we pirating his renders/animations/etc? No. Are we pirating his software? No. Are we sharing his copyrighted material? No.
Pirating is one thing and Stealing something is different.Just saying both is a crime (Illegal), so in a place such as this, it would be like one crook pointing a finger at another and claim they are the bigger one. The creator is pirating though, because he pirate the gfx assets of someone else. He use them in a transformative work, so its not directly plagiarism. It doesn't excuse him of what he did, or give someone credits for the assets doesn't make it right either unless he got a green light from the creators to use said assets.
That is a very valid point. Only a very small amount of developers use real porn images less than 5%.While not the same, there is very little difference between what this dev did and any of the real porn games that use established actors' material.
So... I mean, yeah it sucks that he stole from Devs and Artists, and it should be taken down. But any Dev producing an RP game who getting paid should be facing the same issue. Especially without royalties given to the actors.
render....singular? Not plural?Lol, this guy stolen my shitty render