I do want feedback. But from people who did play my game at least. Not just by reading comments.
I played the game now for the first time and I must say I liked it. BUT.
Something positive, so it isn't a pure rant. I enjoyed the sex scenes with Jen and JenxSally.
But Jen should come clean with whatever she is hiding. MC regrets leaving his family and has it in him to forgive her for whatever happened more so if she is not the one who is ultimately responsible. He knows he made mistakes himself because he believed that was necessary to protect his loved ones.
But the thing is that she started to create more lies to hide the secret and there comes the point where it gets too much and the MC (and more importantly the player) stops trusting her/caring for her. How can you trust someone that has not spoken one sincere sentence to you since you reconnected?
Jen is Central to your story that is at least the impression I have, you need to turn the ship around before we start to hate her (if you look at this threat for some it is already too late).
Then you have only Ashley and the side girls left, which are not directly involved in your Plot. And the Story will probably, be a short one if not even the MC is interested in following the Plot. You can Railroad the character if you need to, you are the dev, but you can't make the player care if you turned them away before that point.
If you want or need some Mystery as a plot device to push your story forward that is fine.
But right now, we have no one, not a single Character, that didn't lie to the MC. Right now he should search for some janitorial service to look after his property and take the next flight to some tropical island paradise, who needs enemies with such friends and family?
(maybe Chloe didn't lie but I threw her out so we didn't talk much)
But for god's sake, dial back the drama, before you strangle your story with those mysteries.