VN Ren'Py Intertwined [v0.13.2] [Nyx]

[LSC82]

I think you're right here too. Even if I still doubt some points, I probably got it in wrong way or got just a little confused anyway. Honestly I thought that it was an Erynn's set-up from the beginning. That she knew about the guy won't show up and craved for MC to attend and participate. But the probability that she might not have known about the most "interesting" part of the photo shoot or just forgot is also quite high.

The outcomes of this choice can also be viewed from the other side. If MC wants more than friendship from her, then theoretically he shouldn't have a problem doing a nude photoshoot with Erynn together. And his refusal rolls back their relationship to the friendzone. Nothing changes when they already in friendzone, but even there she is still upset.

And yeah, Ethan probably is all and fully into his own side and dark business, he is her agent mostly for his own reasons and he don't care that much of her "normal" work she does.

I've been to these things in real life and the models having only the faintest idea of what they are going to be doing is something i can believe quite easily, so i never questioned her not knowing who she was going to be working with or being surprised that they were waiting for "Zane"...
She didn't know who the photographer was going to be either, only after she got there she saw it was the guy who days before held her up for hours.

At some point they would have mentioned topless photos, this is the type of request that probably would've been brought up before signing, but maybe it was only explained after she arrived and she "forgot" about it while being excited to take pictures with the MC...

And Ethan is 100% a shitty agent that only cares about his gains on the dark side of the business, that shouldn't be a question.
It also helps explain how she didn't know anything, the hiring process probably looks like him telling the client "yeah she's available" and then sending her a text to go to this place for a shoot, the end.

Can't blame Nyx for lack of details or attention to them, so yeah. Gabi is not married currently, most probably. But she definitely have some past with Santi. So, it's also quite plausible that she wanted to meet and talk to him at the training camp after race, maybe convince him to have some "fun". In such a case her interest in MC maybe explained that he looks very similar to Santi, which reminds her of him, rather than unhappy marriage with older man or something else.

Nyx put Gabi with a ring in that poster only for her not to have anything in current time, Nyx who loves to insert little details(like Coleman attends the gentleman's club) in her images wouldn't miss that... no way it just slips Nyx's mind continuously.

Adriana also never uses a ring btw .

And yeah they were something to each other, you don't hang a huge picture of your "former agent" in your bedroom wall or keep photos from when you first met in your nightstand.

Exactly. But it must be Santi's permanent lifetime attitude then. It's understandable when you're young, have rich parents and a whole life ahead of you. But kinda strange for about a 40's growed up man. Anyway, different last names, no wedding rings and Patreon rules makes it the most plausible version. It played out once with Andres, Haley and her daughters, so why not repeat something similar again? Thin ice, but trick is being predictable already. Not too much room to experiment here actually.

I believe Nyx is going for a guy who never truly matured, he looks like a respectable member of society... like he's a well adjusted guy in a long term relationship, but in truth he's going behind his "wife" back to fuck younger women, fucks girls he works with(if Gabi is an example)... and probably would fuck Emily again if given the chance.
Kinda of a warning to the player not to enjoy fucking around too much lol.

With all this, i think "they decided to just keep things going like this" kinda works... he's there with Adriana and her daughters... but if necessary he wants to jump ship with as little hassle as possible.

Despite being revealed as a cheater, Andres did want to sign the papers, from how long Santiago seems to be living in that house(with the girls calling him dad seamlessly)... He's probably in this "let's keep it that way, why change something that is working?" for life.

The burning world is better with a blue balls, no shit. So, blackmailing Gabi and fucking Tori just once and then telling her to fuck off (or better losing the race, haha) is a good add-on to the worst playthrough ever Brooke... well, since if someone decided to cosplay MC as a total villain fuckboy and jerk... No flirting, no photo's with this hottie as well. Also "son of the year edition" with 0 RP for Emily, remember? No friends and no hoes, right?

I'm not a big fan of such playthroughs, either. But when game allows you to fuck up almost everything and drags shit and tracks all outcomes till the end - it's fine and deserved to play in such way at least once (completionist is talking).

I get what you are saying, but being in a "relationship" with Tori, who everybody knows has been around the block, isn't exactly loyal and hasn't shown that she cares about you that much (and even then only if you win) it's a nice "prize" for a guy like that.

well what erynn knows wouldn't fill a book.

Truer words have not been spoken.

 

[valbitterb]

Mr. Coleman knew very well why he was there...
i mean he used to date Mel and than a biker asshole came around and stole his girl and got her pregnant!
he may now say he dropped the slag but the truth is that Mel told him to sod off...
to rub salt on his wound 14 years later the child of his shame shows up to his class...

HAIRDRESSER VIXENS, PERVY GEOGRAPHY TEACHERS AND BIKER ASSHOLES

Sounds like a B movie I would enjoy. That's a great love triangle.

Secondly, I don't think that Erynn would had invited MC, especially when they are more than friends to such a photoshoot. Like, you know, "I like you MC, so come on, check out how I will undress in front of the other guy and let him touch me and do stuff on the camera. I bet you'll enjoy it!". She definitely wanted MC to help her and it explains well why they stay only friends after, if MC refuses to participate in photoshoot. And so then, she definitely knew that Zane will not be there in advance. Otherwise it have absolutely no sense.

I agree that it is weird that Erynn is cool with the MC watching her shoot nude pictures with another dude but oh well... and this is something that doesn't change wether the guy is Zane or not, and she knew she was working with "some guy".
The best excuse i can muster is that maybe she didn't know about the nudes until she arrived at the shoot, and maybe she was told while talking to the client and photographer or having her make up done, but yeah very dodgy for her normal behaviour.

In regards to Ethan, he seems quite loose with normal assignments, when Erynn is doing normal modeling jobs he doesn't seem to pay much attention, rarely ever shows up...

I've been to these things in real life and the models having only the faintest idea of what they are going to be doing is something i can believe quite easily, so i never questioned her not knowing who she was going to be working with or being surprised that they were waiting for "Zane"...
She didn't know who the photographer was going to be either, only after she got there she saw it was the guy who days before held her up for hours.

At some point they would have mentioned topless photos, this is the type of request that probably would've been brought up before signing, but maybe it was only explained after she arrived and she "forgot" about it while being excited to take pictures with the MC...

I don't know if any of you guys have mentioned it already, but Erynn seems to have a pattern (Nyx's conscious or unconscious writing choices) to get into situations where potentially another guy gets to watch her doing things naked/half-naked with another guy. The negative version of that is of course the sex tape blackmail narrative thread with Zane and Ethan. The positive version of it is the modeling consensual photo shoot with the MC.

Were it not for the trauma from the sex tape blackmail, I would have thought this would hint at Erynn liking people to watch her and her partner have sex.

And from Gabi's side she never saw you do anything special with Valeria, so she doesn't have anything to say...
She can show jealousy towards Layla however, she's not fully aware of the relationship status but she's seen things.

She also burns daggers into you and Mama Brooke at work. So even though Gabi tells the MC not to fall in love with her, she may be falling herself or is at least quite possessive.

Yeah, it's awful, everything locked... at this point it's just Tori or Gabi(which you may have already blew).
Small hope that Brooke maybe wants to try hetero.

The burning world is better with a blue balls, no shit. So, blackmailing Gabi and fucking Tori just once and then telling her to fuck off (or better losing the race, haha) is a good add-on to the worst playthrough ever Brooke... well, since if someone decided to cosplay MC as a total villain fuckboy and jerk... No flirting, no photo's with this hottie as well. Also "son of the year edition" with 0 RP for Emily, remember? No friends and no hoes, right?

I'm not a big fan of such playthroughs, either. But when game allows you to fuck up almost everything and drags shit and tracks all outcomes till the end - it's fine and deserved to play in such way at least once (completionist is talking).

As Kpyna puts it, if Nyx allows the player to get into burning world, scorched earth or lonely limbo scenarios, does that mean Nyx will write a redemption arc for the MC to get back into everyone's good graces or are we doomed to wander the Earth (Madison Springs) like Cain from the bible with only a hetero-curious Brooke as a distant hope?

(Well, there's still Gina and Sha'Carri. We haven't screwed that up yet. And revenge fucked Natasha to get back at Zach.)

 

[minibaer12]

As Kpyna puts it, if Nyx allows the player to get into burning world, scorched earth or lonely limbo scenarios,

Most people know me as an ardent admirer of this faction and I stand by it too!

does that mean Nyx will write a redemption arc for the MC to get back into everyone's good graces or are we doomed to wander the Earth (Madison Springs) like Cain from the bible with only a hetero-curious Brooke as a distant hope?

Then I say a categorical HELL NOT

 

[Adhdclassic]

HAIRDRESSER VIXENS, PERVY GEOGRAPHY TEACHERS AND BIKER ASSHOLES

Sounds like a B movie I would enjoy. That's a great love triangle.











I don't know if any of you guys have mentioned it already, but Erynn seems to have a pattern (Nyx's conscious or unconscious writing choices) to get into situations where potentially another guy gets to watch her doing things naked/half-naked with another guy. The negative version of that is of course the sex tape blackmail narrative thread with Zane and Ethan. The positive version of it is the modeling consensual photo shoot with the MC.

Were it not for the trauma from the sex tape blackmail, I would have thought this would hint at Erynn liking people to watch her and her partner have sex.




She also burns daggers into you and Mama Brooke at work. So even though Gabi tells the MC not to fall in love with her, she may be falling herself or is at least quite possessive.





As Kpyna puts it, if Nyx allows the player to get into burning world, scorched earth or lonely limbo scenarios, does that mean Nyx will write a redemption arc for the MC to get back into everyone's good graces or are we doomed to wander the Earth (Madison Springs) like Cain from the bible with only a hetero-curious Brooke as a distant hope?

(Well, there's still Gina and Sha'Carri. We haven't screwed that up yet. And revenge fucked Natasha to get back at Zach.)

Thats what I want to do revenge fuck Natasha, Zach needs consequences for his actions. He has been a dick since the get go. He needs a reality check. have all the girls kiss MC and ignore him then have his sister come and kiss him and tell him in front of her brother that she had great night with him. He needs to be destroyed. He who betrays friends walks alone.

 

[Kpyna]

I don't know if any of you guys have mentioned it already, but Erynn seems to have a pattern (Nyx's conscious or unconscious writing choices) to get into situations where potentially another guy gets to watch her doing things naked/half-naked with another guy. The negative version of that is of course the sex tape blackmail narrative thread with Zane and Ethan. The positive version of it is the modeling consensual photo shoot with the MC.

Rather, it's writing in the style of "she's a hostage of the situation", but this is definitely not her type or kind of kink, otherwise she wouldn't be so concerned and downed about the video that Ethan has. Even if her concerns are not only about the video itself, but about teacher career and the things Ethan forces her to do or the alternative he offered to her to escape from this situation. And in photoshoot she is more like excited and feels more relaxed and happy that she is doing it with MC and not a random dude. She definitely got a mental trauma after first time with Zane and the followed consequences and she can't get rid of it even with MC for a while.

As Kpyna puts it, if Nyx allows the player to get into burning world, scorched earth or lonely limbo scenarios, does that mean Nyx will write a redemption arc for the MC to get back into everyone's good graces or are we doomed to wander the Earth like Cain from the bible?

If I'm not wrong we never got a chance to recover from "_End" or "_Friends" states with girls (ASP have a special variable and conditions). So, if it dragged through so much episodes already, then it sounds and feels to me like grounds for "bad" ending(s) or kind of it. Any fixable conflicts and misunderstandings are settled in 1-2 episodes max as we already seen. Telling Layla about Lexi at the pizzeria, rejecting Layla in the camp, declining to help Erynn with her blackmail problem, peeking with Zach on Elena & Sienna in showers, even breaking Layla's heart by picking Elena over her. It's all can be forgiven and MC can explain things in one or another way. But literal betrayals or acting as a jerk seems like a fatal fuck ups with no escape. Not helping Erynn with Ethan when he beats her, fooling with 2 sisters while not telling them, fooling with the person who hated by half of school (Tori) in front of the girl you kinda like (Val). Difference is noticeable and predictable in most of the cases.

Some games doesn't allows you to fail at all, forcing you to choice LI and sticking you to it (LoF). Some allows you to fuck up MCs life (mostly intimate), but most of characters are still friendly to you (BADIK), so you can't get rid of girls and force them to stop talking or be friends with MC. And Intertwined is kinda bigger in this, girls can stop interact with MC and act not friendly towards him. So it makes a much more noticeable difference.

 

[valbitterb]

Rather, it's writing in the style of "she's a hostage of the situation", but this is definitely not her type or kind of kink, otherwise she wouldn't be so concerned and downed about the video that Ethan has. Even if her concerns are not only about the video itself, but about teacher career and the things Ethan forces her to do or the alternative he offered to her to escape from this situation. And in photoshoot she is more like excited and feels more relaxed and happy that she is doing it with MC and not a random dude. She definitely got a mental trauma after first time with Zane and the followed consequences and she can't get rid of it even with MC for a while.

Good points and good way of describing "hostage of the situation".

If I'm not wrong we never got a chance to recover from "_End" or "_Friends" states with girls (ASP have a special variable and conditions). So, if it dragged through so much episodes already, then it sounds and feels to me like grounds for "bad" ending(s) or kind of it.

If that's the case, wow, aside from Brooke, Gina, Sha'Carri, if this is bad ending/s for the MC, a player who chooses this will be stuck in a drama-less, mind numbing limbo of a lot of missed content and being shunned by most of the major ladies for all the game's updates. You might as well quit playing if you end up in this state.

 

[LSC82]

I don't know if any of you guys have mentioned it already, but Erynn seems to have a pattern (Nyx's conscious or unconscious writing choices) to get into situations where potentially another guy gets to watch her doing things naked/half-naked with another guy. The negative version of that is of course the sex tape blackmail narrative thread with Zane and Ethan. The positive version of it is the modeling consensual photo shoot with the MC.

Were it not for the trauma from the sex tape blackmail, I would have thought this would hint at Erynn liking people to watch her and her partner have sex.

You don't get into modeling without at least being ok with being on the spotlight and desired.

Things went waaay further than she wanted, but she still enjoys being "admired", specially by the MC.

She also burns daggers into you and Mama Brooke at work. So even though Gabi tells the MC not to fall in love with her, she may be falling herself or is at least quite possessive.

Yeah, she also asks who we are with at the club... she wants to keep it casual but is failing.

As Kpyna puts it, if Nyx allows the player to get into burning world, scorched earth or lonely limbo scenarios, does that mean Nyx will write a redemption arc for the MC to get back into everyone's good graces or are we doomed to wander the Earth (Madison Springs) like Cain from the bible with only a hetero-curious Brooke as a distant hope?

(Well, there's still Gina and Sha'Carri. We haven't screwed that up yet. And revenge fucked Natasha to get back at Zach.)

Some bridges were definitely burned for good... Erynn, Alexis... Layla i think was more willing to listen to an explanation.
Valeria is just being "team Layla", if Layla softens up, not in a get back together but in a "allowed to hang out with us" i don't think bridges were badly burned here.
Elena and Alexis influence on Layla might make this difficult though.

But yeah tough situation(self created).

Most people know me as an ardent admirer of this faction and I stand by it too!

Then I say a categorical HELL NOT

My favorite style is more manwhore than deliberately bad guy... as Kpyna said you end up without much to do in the full asshole route.
The fun is in trying to have the highest body count possible and still keep every girl believing she's "the one".
Of course it's bound to blow up, but i keep trying to stretch things up as much as possible.

Thats what I want to do revenge fuck Natasha, Zach needs consequences for his actions. He has been a dick since the get go. He needs a reality check. have all the girls kiss MC and ignore him then have his sister come and kiss him and tell him in front of her brother that she had great night with him. He needs to be destroyed. He who betrays friends walks alone.

Yup, i also want to at least make out with Val right in front of him, in the school hall or something.
Sending pictures of her half naked in my bedroom would be even better, but she might not be too happy about that lol.

 

[valbitterb]

You don't get into modeling without at least being ok with being on the spotlight and desired.

Things went waaay further than she wanted, but she still enjoys being "admired".

That's Erynn's thing yes. Good point. If Erynn and the MC get into a relationship, will this enjoyment of being admired cause tensions because the MC is a jealous fuck even when he has no right to be. hahaha.

Yeah, she also asks who we are with at the club... she wants to keep it casual but is failing.

Gabi also gives you and Val a look when you're in the pool. (As auntie Gabi when you haven't screwed Gabi, as jealous Gabi when you've screwed her)

Some bridges were definitely burned for good... Erynn, Alexis... Layla i think was more willing to listen to an explanation.
Valeria is just being "team Layla", if Layla softens up, not in a get back together but in "allowed to hang out with us" i don't think bridges were badly burned here.
Elena and Alexis influence on Layla might make this difficult though.

But yeah tough situation(self created).

Yes. When Layla and Alexis confront you (mostly Alexis), Layla looked disappointed and devastated but not furious.

My favorite style is more manwhore than deliberately bad guy... as @Kpyna said you end up without much to do in the full asshole route.
The fun is in trying to have the highest body count possible and still keep every girl believing she's "the one", of course it's bound to blow up, but i keep trying to stretch things up as much as possible.

The Casanova route? If there are gentleman thieves, I would call this the gentleman manwhore route, and not the outright douchebag love em and leave em manwhore route.

Yup, i also want to at least make out with Val right in front of him, in the school hall or something.
Sending pictures of her half naked in my bedroom would be even better, but she might not be too happy about that lol.

Thats what I want to do revenge fuck Natasha, Zach needs consequences for his actions. He has been a dick since the get go. He needs a reality check. have all the girls kiss MC and ignore him then have his sister come and kiss him and tell him in front of her brother that she had great night with him. He needs to be destroyed. He who betrays friends walks alone.

Since Zach tends to ignore Val while she's talking, I can see Zach blathering on in school with Val about something stupid. Val and the MC just end up making out right in front of him as Zach bursts into flames.

We spied on Natasha and Coach Mike screwing, so hopefully that leads to somewhere with Natasha as a revenge path.

If Natasha didn't go with her family on the ski trip, hopefully we can run into her after the game at Dylan's bar or at the beach the next day.

 

[minibaer12]

My favorite style is more manwhore than deliberately bad guy... as Kpyna said you end up without much to do in the full asshole route.
The fun is in trying to have the highest body count possible and still keep every girl believing she's "the one".
Of course it's bound to blow up, but i keep trying to stretch things up as much as possible.

The game allows us to play the game the way you want to play it. Some approach it constructively and others destructively. The selection of LIs is large and so are their different characters. There is something for everyone.

But the main thing is that you have FUN and feel entertained.

Even if I don't expect a "happy ending", I still hope that at some point in one of my countless routes a "cat fight" will break out between two girls. At least approaches are already there.

But as the saying goes: HOPE DIES LAST!

 

[LSC82]

That's Erynn's thing yes. Good point. If Erynn and the MC get into a relationship, will this enjoyment of being admired cause tensions because the MC is a jealous fuck even when he has no right to be. hahaha.

We can't say right now, some girls enjoy a jealous BF others don't...
She might see your jealousy as "only i'm allowed to look" and might appreciate this.

Gabi also gives you and Val a look when you're in the pool. (As auntie Gabi when you haven't screwed Gabi, as jealous Gabi when you've screwed her)

Yes. When Layla and Alexis confront you (mostly Alexis), Layla looked disappointed and devastated but not furious.

Agree on both.

The Casanova route? If there are gentleman thieves, I would call this the gentleman manwhore route, and not the outright douchebag love em and leave em manwhore route.

More or less lol, let's see how long we can keep the good times going.

Since Zach tends to ignore Val while she's talking, I can see Zach blathering on in school with Val about something stupid. Val and the MC just end up making out right in front of him as Zach bursts into flames.

We spied on Natasha and Coach Mike screwing, so hopefully that leads to somewhere with Natasha as a revenge path.

If Natasha didn't go with her family on the ski trip, hopefully we can run into her after the game at Dylan's bar or at the beach the next day.

Val typically isn't into the whole being manhandled, but grabbing her while she's talking to Zach, kissing her, slapping her ass and delivering a "see you later babe" would be so good... if she's pissed i'll apologize later lol.

And Natasha needs to be recorded, this one 100% gets off on that, so win-win (except for ginger douche).

Even if I don't expect a "happy ending", I still hope that at some point in one of my countless routes a "cat fight" will break out between two girls. At least approaches are already there.

But as the saying goes: HOPE DIES LAST!

I hope so too, if it's family or long time friends dishing out on each other, EVEN BETTER!!!
Bring me the fireworks!!!!

 

[stahlblau]

The game is so good that I constantly curse the developer every time I wake up because there is no update.


Sorry

 

[cxx]

elena and layla fighting over mc: i had sex with him 1st. so what? i kissed him 1st and he saw my naked tits 1st.

mc just sits quietly in corner and smiles.

 

[minibaer12]

The game is so good that I constantly curse the developer every time I wake up because there is no update.


Sorry

This game also needs time to be developed. Nyx also does not belong to the group of sorcerers or magicians. In about half a year we will be smarter.

We are very patient fans...

 

[cxx]

nyx is witch.

 

[valbitterb]

The game allows us to play the game the way you want to play it. Some approach it constructively and others destructively. The selection of LIs is large and so are their different characters. There is something for everyone.

But the main thing is that you have FUN and feel entertained.

Even if I don't expect a "happy ending", I still hope that at some point in one of my countless routes a "cat fight" will break out between two girls. At least approaches are already there.

But as the saying goes: HOPE DIES LAST!

Definitely something for everyone especially our pick of the ladies and our playing styles.

She might see your jealousy as "only i'm allowed to look" and might appreciate this.

Based on how Erynn has behaved when the MC says he's been doing things while thinking about her or thinking about her, seems like she might.

Val typically isn't into the whole being manhandled, but grabbing her while she's talking to Zach, kissing her, slapping her ass and delivering a "see you later babe" would be so good... if she's pissed i'll apologize later lol.

And Natasha needs to be recorded, this one 100% gets off on that, so win-win (except for ginger douche).

Fantastic! Val's kick to the balls will be worth it to see that ginger asshat die from the inside.

Natasha will be adding biological weapon strike to the Val nuclear option against Zach.

The game is so good that I constantly curse the developer every time I wake up because there is no update.


Sorry

It takes a while for the updates but thankfully not as long as other games. It's my favorite game.

 

[minibaer12]

nyx is witch.

oops, I forgot... my mistake

OF COURSE she also belongs to this group!

 

[Kpyna]

Btw, Layla, Elena & MC 3-way relationship path feels like most realistic and plausible. Even if previously all stuff between them happened while they was drunk (train, truth or dare, hot tub), it looks like they both don't mind (most importantly Layla) and including Elena makes her less jealuous. She treasuring her friendship with Layla and this is probably the best "sharing is caring" situation to fit in and work out.

Choice to go for Elena was made for "monogamous" players as I see it. Rejecting Elena and making her leave at the hot tub immideately sets the "_Friends" flag for her, while picking Layla, while having enough points for Elena and option to go for her - not. And, obviously, picking Elena sets the "_Friends" flag for Layla. So, going for Layla, while having Elena on a hook is quite exciting path as for me.

All other girls combos are more likely to scratch each other's eyes out or quarrel forever.

 

[minibaer12]

Btw, Layla, Elena & MC 3-way relationship path feels like most realistic and plausible. Even if previously all stuff between them happened while they was drunk (train, truth or dare, hot tub), it looks like they both don't mind (most importantly Layla) and including Elena makes her less jealuous. She treasuring her friendship with Layla and this is probably the best "sharing is caring" situation to fit in and work out.

Choice to go for Elena was made for "monogamous" players as I see it. Rejecting Elena and making her leave at the hot tub immideately sets the "_Friends" flag for her, while picking Layla, while having enough points for Elena and option to go for her - not. And, obviously, picking Elena sets the "_Friends" flag for Layla. So, going for Layla, while having Elena on a hook is quite exciting path as for me.

All other girls combos are more likely to scratch each other's eyes out or quarrel forever.

Unfortunately I have to disappoint you here. There will be no such thing as a three-way relationship, because at the latest when things get “serious” the fun is over! You'll lose one, it's just the question; HOW!

 

[Trojaner]

Unfortunately I have to disappoint you here. There will be no such thing as a three-way relationship, because at the latest when things get “serious” the fun is over! You'll lose one, it's just the question; HOW!

Easy Peasy ... Answer:
The one ya lose will be Run over by a train. Tschoooo Tschoooo *Muahaha*

 

[LSC82]

Based on how Erynn has behaved when the MC says he's been doing things while thinking about her or thinking about her, seems like she might.

I think so, for example if we meet Zane in the beach, i'm thinking with going full "she's mine" at first.
And let's see how she reacts to that...

Fantastic! Val's kick to the balls will be worth it to see that ginger asshat die from the inside.

Natasha will be adding biological weapon strike to the Val nuclear option against Zach.

Flag Val_Pissed_Off and Val -8!!!
Still worth it lol.

Btw, Layla, Elena & MC 3-way relationship path feels like most realistic and plausible. Even if previously all stuff between them happened while they was drunk (train, truth or dare, hot tub), it looks like they both don't mind (most importantly Layla) and including Elena makes her less jealuous. She treasuring her friendship with Layla and this is probably the best "sharing is caring" situation to fit in and work out.

Choice to go for Elena was made for "monogamous" players as I see it. Rejecting Elena and making her leave at the hot tub immideately sets the "_Friends" flag for her, while picking Layla, while having enough points for Elena and option to go for her - not. And, obviously, picking Elena sets the "_Friends" flag for Layla. So, going for Layla, while having Elena on a hook is quite exciting path as for me.

All other girls combos are more likely to scratch each other's eyes out or quarrel forever.

Layla sees the MC kiss her BFF and suck her titties and it didn't change her mind that the MC is worth taking her cherry, all the jealousy she has towards other girls doesn't extend to Elena.
And they are often kissing each other anyway...

If you said to Layla that you prefer Elena it's tough to come back from that... you basically told her she's always going to be the third wheel if sharing were to happen, not to mention she's still a virgin.
With Layla as the first i think it's easier to convince Elena that you love both equally, you just happened to meet Layla first.

This seems the more believable possibility of sharing, compare this to the suppousedly BFFs Alexis and Erynn and it's a completely different picture, some love but also a little bit of a cold war between those 2 (hopefully i can make nukes start flying ).