So much text for a misunderstanding, that is quite funny! If you read my post correctly, you will see that I mentioned bad Karma in relation to the MC mostly, less Mina, even if she gets some too if you and her cheat on Ian. How we players act on this is TD´s first major moral test of the game, just not in the face type.
I once again say that two wrongs do not make a right. Ian certainly needs a wake-up call (which we can at least partly give him) and is the one responsible for what is coming his way, but that still does not make cheating right.
As we could see during the birthday truth or dare, Ian would have been ok with Mina doing it with Edwin, but openly, not like tihs. As said, it is one thing if Edwin and Mina come together after the break up or if Edwin helps Mina cheating. Esp. since we should not forget that there is the posibility that Ian (if he starts manning up and thinks about the future) and Mina might make up later on in the game.
But personally, I can even see an epilogue with Ian teaching History at a school or university and being in a relationship with Viktoria or Mina.
i wasn't attacking your post, it just have the most info so i quoted it.
Counting Mina action as cheating is only right under heavy moral culture influenced, i'm asian too but live in a western environment all my life so i know where you're coming from, but to most her action are very mild and it should not at all a problem with open minded friends which illustrated in the game.
I am bad, i want her to be happy, she's happy with my friend and he can make her happy the way i can, i can entrust her to him without worrying about her being sad like when she's with me
, this is normal, even romantic dramas illustrate it many times, even when they didn't break up yet, it's already over.
And you ask why the hell Mina didn't breakup first before doing things to our MC, well, why didn't Ian do it? Saying two wrong doesn't make a right is only an alternative way of saying "Ian was wrong, but whos care, She shouldn't do it because i don't accept her doing that just because the others did", like heck no,
I don't stab someone in the back because they haven't hurt me before, so i shouldn't, and that good.
But if someone stab my back multiple times already, i think i should have the options, if i don't stab them back and forgive them and move on and be good and be saint, well that's good. BUT i should have option to choose to do whatever the hell i want, break them, stab them back, date their friends, hurt them, cheat them, or forgive them, that my choice, it's punishment, whether that punishment is on me or the person stabbing me, doesn't matter, no one should be allowed to judge it, Like, why the hell does Mina have to think about how everyone feel, carefully choose what to do, what to say, how to act for that "consequences" that might or might not happening, when she is hurt herself? and she should do this, should do that, it's morally right, blah blah, you should try replay the game and make choices so MC have sex with her, what she said during that times is enough for me to defend her choice, and i am a man, not even woman.
Ian already broken, the only way he can heal and become teacher like you said is by Mina leaving his life, which make him rethink about his life now that he's lost something important by his own hand, then he can reflect, develope to be better
Right or wrong is only based on individual perspective in her case, i'm just a deep thinker
