Well sounds like your doing all the right stuff, and the Riley scene was perfect, i did a second playthrough and got the scene i missed on my first run, i know not all want the full package as you said but i loved it and i was very supprrised to see you had put blood in it since thats somewhat rare, so for my taste you did it perfectly with Riley.That's fair. Each to their own. I'm basically taking some creative liberties to say that dildos don't count as much in my game, simply because I personally think the use of dildos is hot, and wanted to do scenes with them, but I didn't think dealing with defloration in a dildo scene was something I wanted to do, at least not without MC present. So I basically operate on the idea that while the girls have hymens, they're not necessarily as fragile as real life ones. It's a trade off between realism, and what kind of scenes are actually possible. Female orgasm is also a pretty big theme in the game, so I wanted to make sure that it happens in basically every scene where a girl is getting stimulated, unless the point of the scene is to not allow it. Hard to do that while remaining realistic for virgins without just swearing off penetration of any kind for them until after their virginity is taken.
All of that said, while I didn't make the girls virgins specifically so that I could include defloration scenes, I'm not planning to shy away from them for the majority of the virgin girls. They won't all be like Riley's first possible one, but I'm not gonna be pretending that a virgin who's barely had anything inside them at all is immediately a master at taking dick. This changes somewhat on some routes due to the influence of the collars, but at very least the romance route defloration scenes should match the character's experience at the time, even if that experience is with toys.
I'm also kinda working with the idea that different girls do have different hymen types and sizes, so just because one of the virgin girls may have been able to take a dildo, another of the virgin girls may not. It remains to be seen, but they're not just virgins because I wanted to be able to put the virgin tag on the game.
I also agree dildos are hot and love them in games, i can see how it would be a challenge to not do penetrations before their virginity is taken, but it depens on how you plan to put in choices doing reward/punishment scenes if the player has the options to use a dildo or use something else like a magic wand vibrator that wont need penetration to get the girls off.
But i am happy that you put in some real thoughts on this stuff and i would never expect all to be the same as Rileys first, wouldent be right for a girl like Cassie, but for someone like Hakari it would make more then sense considering her stats.
But i am looking forward to see what happens next, great job so far and i droped a 5 star review as well hoping it will help to get more people aware of this game since its well deserved.