Jessica is a good pick, but I don't know, if she'd be mine.
Madelyn would probably have been my pick, but I don't think she counts. As she has her own thing going on in the sequel.
I like Naomi's model a lot, but I don't think her promiscuous nature. Would allow her, to get in a serious relationship.
Janet is a bit boring in my book and her model doesn't exactly stand above the rest.
From the times I've been here and peeked a little into this thread. There seems to have been a bit of a general discontent with Alia. I'm fond of her personallity. With some more years for that personality to mature and hopefully still keep that inner spark and brightness. And for her body to hopefully grow a bit more in the right places. Alia would probably be my pick.
The librarian and "not" Lara Croft didn't quite grow on me.
Tanya the barmaid is probably my last pick. I find her annoying, but I can see how her brash nature, could be endearing to other people.
"Sofia" really started to grow on me. I feared in the start, that she would just be a rich bitch eventually seduced by big cock throughout the entire game. As strange as it is to me, Sofia would probably be my pick. She was amoung the least favourite of the girls for me in the first few iterations of the game.
Jessica a close second to me.
Haley or Alia in my third place.