Warning long post ahead
So I did a replay to refresh my memory of all the events so far in the game and to see how they hold up to the critics that were made.
Starting with the obvious the rape of the woman of the house, now when I first played the game I thought it was unnecessarily extreme that all of them were raped, having a better context helps to understand how it's possible and while I still think it's too extreme I can understand why they would allow it to happen, I still feel there needs to be a clearer explanation because it did seem that they didn't try to stop it, being afraid of him is understandable, but when it happens to all of them they should have done something, fortunately something did happen.
I don't agree that the people that didn't like that setup, are too sensitive or projecting too much, rape has unfortunately become a easy way to add drama to a story, its overuse is so great that when you see it happen, you can't help but feel that its used as a cheap way to create drama, I don't think that is the case here but the people that think it is are not exactly wrong in assuming that it is.
Right now the tone of the story its quite dark, even depressing considering that despite everything he did the father more or less got away with it since he died in a mostly peaceful way while the people of the town think he's a great guy who helped everyone and even the women of the house seem to have develop an extreme Stockholm syndrome since they all try to justify what he did.
right now the story need something good to happen, something that balances the dark aspect of it, if only bad things keep happening the story is at risk of loosing itself in its own depression causing the player to give up and stop playing because everyone has a really shitty life and there is no indication that it can have a happy ending for anyone.
I like the basic premise of the story and while I don't fully agree with the way it's presented I do wish to see how it develops, lets just stop assuming that anyone that doesn't like its just angry that there's no virgins left, people have the right to dislike the story, that doesn't make them wrong its their opinion