- Dec 24, 2018
- 1,755
- 9,667
This is a well thought out criticism, so I am not bashing (especially as I am the newbie). Flip your perspectives and see the from the other side. You would rather he abandoned WIAB because he spends more perceptible time on SG. Currently he cares enough about WAIB to not abandon it, and posts regularly showing progress. What your argument seems to be is "WIAB is not living up to the potential I feel it could reach because SG is leeching away energy, I would rather have nothing than wasted potential." It's a fair statement.I have read this post so many times trying to figure out if I should say something about it... Ignore it, report it, reply to it, agree, disagree. People can do whatever with this. Its a serious post, so its a bit on the long side
I agree to some degree when you say that things arent being sweetened here... And yes, I do read the thread. And because I read it, I know that what you said isnt particularly true...
Sure some people like yourself try to provide good feedback and Im not denying that, but as much as you "tell it like it is" theres always some sort of sweetening attached to it like in the post Im replying. Example: "Chapter 2 was short? yes, compared to SG, it was a sigh. And so? I liked it just the same."... All the fans liked it to some extent and to be honest I didnt mind that the update was small. Seems like a lot of the followers of Ocean always have a "but" on their sentences... "It took a long time BUT I liked it"; "Chapter 3 will be short BUT theres Miru"; "...BUT now with the new equipment..."
It makes me sad how Ocean is treating this game, a game that when I joined F95 was one of those rare ones that coupled good renders with an amazing story when you did realize that it was his first game. Sure it needed some "refining" but thats to be expected from a 1st game.
Now I just wished he abandoned this game... Its always getting delayed, its always "on the back seat" of SG (makes sense, since SG is the one thats making him more money I guess). Imagine having a game with one of the best potentials in the AVN industry as a "backup" . Another month where SG jumped the line and I cant be surprised . Also, the problem arent the yearly releases... Many games do them to good effect but they have to have the content to justify it
Concluding: I cant understand the trust a lot of people put on Ocean since to me he has done almost nothing to deserve it. Maybe my standards are too high ... F95 should be a place where a dev comes for "real reviews and crticicism" but everyone who does a bit of criticism on this dev gets either ignored being labeled a troll that people shouldnt "feed" or gets called out on it and then doesnt have a spine to present the proof of what they are saying
Consider maybe a differnet view - Ocean is developing one story told through several games. He has chosen to push the more popular one so he can get enough support to push the whole story, WIAB and the other parts that he's already planned. Ocean doesn't see time spent of SG as detrimental to WIAB, as the plot to SG forces him to consider what came before and make it more iron clad/more solid canon. SG is far easier to market, even if in time it is the youngling. Ocean is developing the canon of the whole story, with the advantage he can do something quite profound with interwoven narratives.
Still, this is all personal poinions, and a dev can expect endless patience. But patrons and fans are precisely the people who believe that an artist should be allowed to pursue there vision. Cynical, bitter fans sap energy. In music terms it's like the people who say, "play your old songs, the new ones suck." I would rather that SG's success allows Ocean the opportunity to make WIAB a success and continue the whole saga for the rest of the stories.
As far as trusting Ocean, trust is a gift, and isn't always deserved. It isn't cause and effect, not a natural law. To trust is to risk without experience. I have to suspend disbelief to trust. BUt as far as I know, Ocean has spent enough time money and effort driving this project that I doubt he'll walk away from WIAB. In some ways WIAB is harder as people have more expectations based on the previous iteration: SG has already passed all the rework material so it is pretty getting exciting new material each update, while WIAB is still catching up to where it was in the plot, and deviations feel strange because we're comparing what went before with what there is now. Once WIAB passes beyong the territory covered in the pre rework, I think it will start to shine , and it will be stronger for the development of SG - overall WIAB is pushing the renders on SG to meet the Steam release, which means WIAB will benefit from every optimisation he learns on the way.
I don't understand why we place success and failure as the only options while someone is actively working and mentioning what they're working on in both games. Plenty of devs don't even have remotely the same consistency with logs. The thing that is disappointing is the wait, but it's only disappointing because we believe the story is good.