Mr. Coatl's Game Catalogue Replayability Tierlist(s) W/ In-Site Annotations

5.00 star(s) 1 Vote

Mr. Coatl

Newbie
Mar 27, 2018
72
190
For Storage Purposes I've been going through my Catalogue and I thought it'd be fun to make a tierlist because lists are pretty fun.

------------------THINGS OF NOTE------------------
-This initial list is from the games I've haven't finished yet, either being games that I downloaded and haven't played yet or games that I've touched a couple times but haven't finished. The List proper will come when I have much more time.
-All games (barring special circumstances) will be linked to somewhere in F95 as, again, barring certain games, every one that I've downloaded has been from here.
-Criteria is based on weather I enjoyed it as a game primarily before its ranked on H-Quality (art, h-mechanics, dialogue). This is subject to change.
-I might explain why I put games in their tiers later if I have even more free time.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Remember just because its in a list doesn't mean it isn't almost entirely Vibes Based
---------UNCOMPLETED/RETURNING GAME TIER LIST---------
The following are games that I either haven't touched yet or haven't completed yet and rated by how likely I am to come back to and finish them
" - "Mean it was filed under "In Progress"
" * " Mean it was filed under the sub-folder of "unopened"
(neither was a very good way to file those and sorta unindicative)

Absolutely Will get back to/Working on it.
-VHMV (Unable to link for Rule 7)
-VenusBlood FRONTIER

Interested in getting back in
-Oppai no Ouja 48
*Legendary Cumblade of PRINCESS REINA
*Parasite Day -LABORATORY-
*Yuno Fantasy (translation thread only; there's an MTL in there but I can't say how good it is)

Maybe much later
-Aria and the Secret of the Labyrinth
-Celestia the Princess of Fellati

Probably not
-Mirelle and Amurita, the Forest of Illusions
*Receptionist Ferris
*Night of the Sexual Beast and the Fallen Saint
*PhantomAlchemy ~Silvia's Dynamic Urban Planning~
*Demon's Roots
*Kobold's Knight of Livestock (translation thread only; there's an MTL in there but I can't say how good it is)

Unopened/ N/A
*War Demon Kirsten
*BLACK SOULS
*Life is Paradise

Interested Unopened
*Dungeons and Prisoners (translation thread only; there's an MTL etc. etc)
*The elf slave Feinne, why did she sell out her own country?
*Heroine Rorona, Soul Slave and Seedbed of Monsters (translation thread only, blah blah blah)
*Rebecca and the sword of Nasty Curses

COMPLETE DOWNLOADED REPLAYABILITY LIST
Once again, reminder, the contents of this list is my backlog of games that I had in my external hard drive and the parameters for placement are primarily weather I thought the game was fun enough to go back to and then weather I thought the H-Content was good.

Completed, Very Good
-Alien Quest: Eve (+mods)
-Cursed Armor
-Monster Girl Club Bifrost
-Flying Princess Interbreed (tobihime?)
-Goblins Strike Back, Goblin Adventurer Hunting (V.2), Ero Trap Roguelike Dungeon (v.2)
-Haramase Simulator
-Introducing an Apprentice Incubus
-Imperial Gatekeeper (This link is the Procrastinatus Content Patch)
-Karryn's Prison (+mod)
-Monster Black Market
-Melty's Quest
-Parasite in City
-Vitamin Quest
-Silent Pill
-SiNiSistar
-She Ill Server
-Encode Encore (V.2)
-Lets Go! My Harem Farm (V.2)

Unfinished, Very Good
-Agnietta
-Drop Factory
-Key of Egg
-Pronant Symphony
-Wings of Roldea
-Witch-in-Debt's Pornalicious Adventures
-Princess Knight Claris
-Celesphonia
*Lisette, Priestess of Spring Pregnancy
-Lethargic Angel Lacks Sexual Credits (V.2)
-Degrees of Lewdity (V.2)
-Curious Tales of Yaezujima -Rinko Kageyama's Endless Summer- (Goblinman mod)(V.2)

Completed, Pretty Good
-Haramase Island
-Brave Alchemist Colette
-BlazingAngel Mistletear
-Breedtown
-Become Tentacle Attack Castle
-Elise the Devil
-Paid Dating Fantasy
-Forget-Me-Not Gemini Fort
-Hazumi in the Pregnation (+mods)
-Jumble Strikers
-Kabopuri Series (Fully Mature, Early Stages, 2 Momo/Karin, 3 Sand Dancer/Diva Songstress)
-Liz of the Tower (breeding mod specifically)
-National Affairs of the Queen
-Salvation (there's a mod attached to this one but idk)
-Sword Maiden of the Azure Dragon
-Treasure Hunter Clair
-Imperial Harem (V.2)
-Impregnation of the Elves (v.2)
-Tentacles and Asuna (v.2)
-Peeping Dorm Manager (v.2)
-Syahata's Bad Day (v.2)
-The Black Labyrinth (v.2)
-Kagura Eris Dysnomia (v.2)


Unfinished, Pretty Good
-Lewd World Sacrifice Araka
-Bitch Exorcist Rio (series)
-Goblin Burrow (Ill Borne, the Fable)
-Dungeon of Lulu Fareah, Kill Screw Marry
-Lilitales
-Monster Girl 1000
-Orc of Ambitia
-Ruins Seeker
-Strive for (Power and Conquest)
*Mary Go Land
-Castle Evil (v.2)
-Lust Prison (v.2)
-Yukiya Onsen the Waters of Fertility (v.2)
-PERFECT CELLS PROJECT (v.2)

Basically Finished, Pretty Good
-Annelitte
-Rignetta's Adventure
-Outmaneuver!! NN Pick-Up Beach (v.2)
-Dungeon's Legion (v.2)


Completed, Alright
-Bitch JK in an RPG
-Captive Princess Marie and the Castle of Depraved Monsters
-Chris Survival
-Kamikaze Kommitee Oukia
-Lala and the Bizarre Dungeon
-Miss Kyoko Wants to Get Laid
-Neko-ronomicon
-The Manager Serves All
-Touch Tail Girl
-Tentacle Dungeon (v.2)
-Motherhood Awakening - Hypnotic ETD (v.2)

Unfinished, Alright
-Cursed Armor II (lol, lmao even)
-Sakura Dungeon
-Evil Guards of the Merchant City
*Alchemist's Fantasy R ~ A Girl's Alchemic Furnace ~
*Night of Revenge
-Violated Princess (TL thread only for rule reasons but you can find something there) (v.2)
-My Girlfriend Advanced to the Dancer Class and now she buffs Everybody (v.2)
-Tentacles Invasion (v.2)
-Summer Memories Plus (v.2)

Unfinished, Don't Really Plan On Going Back
-Nako's Magic and the Monster of Pure Desire ~The Crystals of Malice~

Don't Even Really Remember, Probably Pretty Good
-Flower Witch
-Princess Go Round
-Elena Migrant Maiden
-Seed of Evil

Don't Even Really Remember, Probably Alright
-Escape From Wombraid Maze
-Fallen Makina
-Marle: The Labyrinth of the Black Sea
-The NPC Fucking "Unlimited Fucking from town girl to Queen Demon"
-Women's Defence
-Flower Charm Sequel - Mansion of Captivation
*The Island of Demonic Birth: The Vice President Who Fell into the Sexual Processing Committee

Not Touched Enough To Decide
-Bible Violet
-Carnal Desires
-DohnaDohna
-Fate Empire of Dirt
-Ideology in Friction
-Miss Lisette's Assassin Maid
-Meritocracy of the Oni and Blade
-Reign of the Succubus
*Para Ark
-I Won't Be Corrupted- Tale of the Naive Elven Swordswoman (v.2)

Untouched (apparently)
-Ariadne
-Dangerous Road Home at Night
-Monster Girl Quest
-Reincarnated as a Succubus
-Succubus Game
-Slice of Venture Origins
-Last Harem (v.2)
-Secret Casino (v.2)
-Rina Quest! I am become Bikini Warrior (v.2)
-The Worlds Egg - For Those Who Dream (v.2)
-Rabbit Ear Adventurer and the Naughty Carrot (v.2) (TL thread only there's an MTL but its pretty rough)
-Tentacle Fall Trap (v.2)
-Bunny Girl's Strange Alien Adventure (v.2)
-The Mercenary's Adventure (v.2)
-Marauder of Dystopia: The Weakest Go to the Wall (v.2)
-Slimy Sextet (v.2)
-The Demon Lord's Treasure (v.2)
Update Eagerly Awaited
-Dungeon Lord: A New Beginning
-Iris in the Labyrinth of Demons
-Marie's Adventures
-Renryuu Ascension
-Vitamin Quest 2 (Update to Translation anyway)
-Yagiri's (Link to Kemono for all versions)
-SiNiSistar 2
-ThornSin
-Project R (v.2)
-Princess Reconquista (v.2)


Active Development, We'll See Later
*Hounds of the Meteor
*Wolf of Shadow
-Lona
-Slice of School

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Key:
Completed:
Self Explanatory. Played the game from start to finish or at least to the level of finished to my personal satisfaction
Unfinished: Self Explanatory, I got a certain amount of the way though and then stopped for one reason or another.
Don't Even Really Remember: I got a Bad Memory gang, and some of these have been here for years I won't remember everything
Not Touched Enough to Decide: I probably spent like 3-4 hours in any of these games if that I can't really make a sound decision based on that.
Untouched (apparently): The file I had these under assumed that I'd touched the game at some point but I don't remember even starting these.
Update Eagerly Awaited: These are all being updated in one way or another and I am very much looking forward to most of them.
Game Title Is Underlined: I cannot recommend this game enough. This game is either very fun, has very good H-content or both. If you are reading this you should stop and play this sometime soon.
V.#: Game was added in the # Version of the list (2nd, 3rd, etc.)
Very Good: This game was either fun to play or had very memorable H-content, most likely both. I have come back to these games repeatedly.
Pretty Good: This game was fairly fun as far as H-Games go and the scenes were pretty good. I've either thought about going back to these games or gone back to them once or twice.
Alright: Game was overall pretty Okay; game loop was probably good and the scenes were probably decent I could go back to these but there are better options
Don't Really Plan On Going Back: This was definitely for someone and I'm sure someone found this interesting but I couldn't get into it. The only reason it was probably still around was because I hadn't gotten around to deleting it and then forgot about it.

Edit 1: Added ThornSin. Super good Rouge like (minor but important differences) with getting pregnant, carrying, and giving birth as a main mechanic. Very short rn. Very good.

Edit 2: Added the "Active Development, We'll See Later" Tier for in dev games that I'm cautiously optimistic about but are just ok right now. As well as shuffled some games around based on more time put in and more time thinking about it. Got rid of "Basically Already Done" as it's games were all moved elsewhere and the whole tier seemed altogether kind of redundant​
 
Last edited:

f9account

Engaged Member
Mar 20, 2020
2,182
1,975
Nice work, especially with the tentacle breeding part, it's so rare to see it done well.
 

Mr. Coatl

Newbie
Mar 27, 2018
72
190
Working on updating the list soon as my hard drive is nearly full and its a good way to make some space for new stuff. In the mean time and slightly off topic (I guess), I never got around to finishing my playthrough of Celesphonia and I've since learned that there's a really neato mod by a Chinese modder and here is a link to where you can get it in the forum adds a lot and really adds to the game in a good way. Supposedly anyway I probably won't pick it up anytime soon. Just because I've been focusing on other, non-h games things for right now.
 

Mr. Coatl

Newbie
Mar 27, 2018
72
190
List has been updated for all the games I've played since I last updated it! Some stuff has been moved around after further consideration and additional categories have been made with them.

Additional notes:
*Ultra big shoutout to Fate/ Stay Night which I have read and finished in between the makings of the lists I would rank it extremely high but I also recognize that in terms of gameplay and H-Scenes its INCREDIBLY lacking. Mostly because its an orthodox VN and the scenes are notoriously bad on average. Story rocks socks though and can really hit if you're open to it.
-Tentacle Dungeon is ranked highly (comparatively) but its like, a poser really. Good if you're looking for art references but otherwise pretty meh. Likewise Tentacles and Asuna is a game that you can get though within 30 minutes easy but the content is kinda exactly what I'm looking for so I put it really high.
-To that note Goblin Adventurer Hunting, and Ero Trap Roguelike Dungeon has been grouped with Goblins Strike Back because they're basically the same game. Dev iterates on the formula in every new game but at its core its still basically the same thing. I'm super into the game they're making but if you're not I really don't know what to tell you. Consequence of Vibes Based Ranking system
-Syahata's Bad Day was apparently made with some AI influence (allegedly) if that affects anything for you.
-I think Lust Prison is something like 10+ gigs altogether or something wacky like that. Takes forever to unzip and move around.
*While I was looking for the games to link them I found this gentleman's tierlist with a similar bend to this one. It has more an emphasis on gameplay and bends a little more to platformers and I thought a diffent perspective would be neat, to offset my obvious bias towards RPGMaker games.​
 
  • Like
Reactions: zozogazygua
5.00 star(s) 1 Vote